Compare: Cattaraugus County vs Central Islip

Home Values in Cattaraugus County and Central Islip

Cattaraugus County
vsCentral Islip
Zillow Home Value Index

Zillow Home Value Index

Mid-point of Zestimate valuations for Cattaraugus. Half the Zestimates are above this number and half are below it.
$69,700vs$242,700
1-Year Change-4.0%vs+16.5%
Median List Price$99,000vs$235,000
Median Sale Price$74,300vs$239,100

Cattaraugus County, NY tends to be less expensive for home buyers than Central Islip, NY. During the last year, Cattaraugus County home values have fallen by 4.0%, while Central Islip home values have risen by 16.5%. The median sale price in Cattaraugus County is $74,300, but the median listing price was $99,000, a 24.9% discount. Meanwhile in Central Islip, the median selling price is $239,100, and the starting price had a median of $235,000, a 1.7% increase.

Homes for Sale in Cattaraugus County and Central Islip

Cattaraugus County vs Central Islip
Cattaraugus County
9   GREER HILL DR  18 Photos
  • 9 GREER HILL DR
  •  House For Sale: $1,499,000
  • Beds: 6
    Baths: 4.0
    Sqft: 4,877
    Lot: 14,810
21 W Washington St  27 Photos
Central Islip
1104   Connetquot Ave  6 Photos
43   Bayonne Ave  20 Photos
  • 43 Bayonne Ave
  •  House For Sale: $459,000
  • Beds: 4
    Baths: 2.0
    Sqft: 2,032
    Lot: 13,939

Would you rather own a house in Cattaraugus County or Central Islip? Why?

Nearby real estate