152 Division St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

5 beds3.5 baths5,376 sqft Edit

Edit home facts for a more accurate Zestimate.
Sold: $1,555,000
Sold on 06/27/14
Zestimate®: $4,682,301
Est. Mortgage

Estimated Monthly Payment


Please enter a dollar amount between $0 and $200,000,000


Please enter a percent between 0% and 100%

30 Year Fixed:
15 Year Fixed:
5/1 ARM:
Estimated taxes & insurance of are not included.
See current rates On

A Zestimate® home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more

My Notes

In 1842 Abe Lincoln weds Mary Todd, the University of Notre Dame was founded, ether debuts as the anesthetic of choice and the adhesive backed postage stamp adheres to its first letter. That same year, in the bustling whaling village of Sag Harbor, a wonderful 2 story, 3 bedroom home completed construction on a quarter acre along Division Street. Eight score and 11 years later, that same residence, variously expanded and renovated over the years to include a two bedroom guest house on a half acre is ready for its next owner to perhaps bring it even further into the 21st century. Original details balance nicely with modern amenities throughout the residence which offers gracious living room and adjacent parlor, both warmed by fireplaces, spacious eat-in kitchen, enclosed sun porch and convenient first floor bedroom. Upstairs, a separate certificate of occupancy legalizes another kitchen and two more bedrooms which could make the second floor its own separate apartment. Outside the charming property leads to a 2 bedroom, one bath guest house with living room and kitchen prime for the weekend overflow or for rental possibilities. Navigate Main Street to have sunset drinks at B. Smiths, then stroll to the American Hotel for dinner and perhaps finish up with an ice cream at Big Olaf. With an in-town location, three separate C of O's, in the only Hampton village where its wharf meets Main Street, this ode to another era beckons those longing for their own compound and a piece of history.  More Less 


  • Lot: 0.25 acres
  • Single Family
  • Built in 1994
  • All time views: 2,165
  • Heating: Other
  • Last sold: Jun 2014 for $1,555,000
  • Last sale price/sqft: $289


  • Fireplace


      • Exterior material: Metal
      • Stories: 2
      • Structure type: Other
      • Unit count: 2


      • Floor size: 5,376 sqft
      • Parcel #: 0903003000400040001
      • Zillow Home ID: 32720472

      Zestimate Details

      A Zestimate home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more

      The Value Range is the high and low estimate market value for which Zillow values a home. The more information, the smaller the range, and the more accurate the Zestimate. See data coverage and accuracy table

      Don't agree with your home's Zestimate? Owners can edit their home facts to make the Zestimate more accurate. Plus, you can leave an opinion on your Zestimate value below. Just click "Owner Estimate".
      -$423,277 Last 30 days
      Zestimate range
      Rent Zestimate A Rent Zestimate is Zillow's estimated monthly rental price, computed using a proprietary formula. It is a starting point in determining the monthly rental price for a specific property. Learn more

      The Rent Range is the high and low estimate for which an apartment or home could rent. The more information we have, the smaller the range, and the more accurate the Rent Zestimate. See data coverage and accuracy table
      -$4,032 Last 30 days
      Zestimate range
      Zestimate forecast
      One year
      To see Zestimate forecast
      Create a free account

      Improve This Home's Value

      Mid-Range Minor Kitchen Remodel

      • See all Kitchens

      • Estimated value increase: $20.2K

      • The average cost for a mid-range minor kitchen remodel in Sag Harbor is $19,957.

      Mid-Range Bathroom Remodel

      • See all Bathrooms

      • Estimated value increase: $9.4K

      • The average cost for a mid-range bathroom remodel in Sag Harbor is $17,497.

      Comparable Homes

      Homes like this sold for $2.37-4.75M.


      Sell your home on Zillow

      If this home is listed on Zillow, it will reach the largest real estate network on the web.*
      Forecasted views
      if you listed your home for sale
      Rental views
      if posted for rent
      all-time (chart)


      Neighborhood: 11963

      Zillow predicts 11963 home values will rise 1.6% next year, compared to a 3.2% rise for Sag Harbor as a whole. Among 11963 homes, this home is valued 430.9% more than the midpoint (median) home, but is valued 46% less per square foot.

      Foreclosures will be a factor impacting home values in the next several years. In 11963, the number of foreclosures waiting to be sold is 24.1% less than in Sag Harbor, and 19% less than the national average. This lower local number could help 11963 home values rise more quickly than other regions in Sag Harbor.
        read more Less 


        For Sale

        See all nearby listings


        See all nearby rentals

        Nearby Schools in Sag Harbor

        GreatSchools ratings give an overview of a school's test results. The ratings are based on a comparison of test results for all schools in the state.

        Disclaimer: School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics and are subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.

        Data by GreatSchools.org