6 Wesley Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

4 beds2 baths2,232 sqft Edit

Edit home facts for a more accurate Zestimate.
Sold: $800,000
Sold on 10/28/14
Zestimate®: $747,016
Est. Mortgage

Estimated Monthly Payment


Please enter a dollar amount between $0 and $200,000,000


Please enter a percent between 0% and 100%

30 Year Fixed:
15 Year Fixed:
5/1 ARM:
Estimated taxes & insurance of are not included.
See current rates On

A Zestimate® home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more

My Notes

One of the rare Shelter Island Heights homes that is in original condition and sited in a lovely park-like setting with views of the grove adjacent to historic Union Chapel. Built in 1890, this summer cottage is bordered with tall privet and has French doors both on the first floor and the second floor, unifying the outdoors to the interiors. A spacious screened porch doubles as an outdoor living room in the summertime. Just inside the entry is the living room, which comprises the entire width of the front of the home, sitting parlor and formal dining room. The kitchen is in the rear overlooking the garden, and has an outdoor screened foyer with full bath, sitting area and serving for outdoor dining. The second floor features a master suite with cathedral ceilings, French doors with petite balcony, and dressing area. There are also two additional guest rooms, also with cathedral ceilings and hall bath with original ball and claw tub. Just outside the rear entry is a guest suite with reading and relaxation area. The grounds are exceptionally large for the Heights and invite one to wander and observe nature. Located on a quiet lane within stone's throw to ferry, this is Hamptons country living at its best. Square footage shown includes 300 +/- sq. ft. guesthouse. Penelope Moore, Lic Assoc Broker, 917-208-5519, info@penelope-moore.com.  More Less 


  • Lot: 0.37 acres
  • Single Family
  • Built in 1890
  • Views: 3,843 all time views
  • Last sold: Oct 2014 for $800,000
  • Last sale price/sqft: $358


  • Parking: Garage - Detached, 2 spaces

      Additional Features

      • Apartment Type \ no, Basement Type \ Partial, Building Style \ no, Construction Type \ no, Garage Type \ Detached, Property Type \ Single Family Detached, Residential Style \ Cottage, Sewer Type \ Community, View City \ no, View Lake \ no, View Mountain \ no, View Ocean \ no, View Park \ no, View Pond \ no, View Private \ no, View River \ no, View Scenic \ no, View Stream \ no, View Street \ no, View Type \ no, View Wooded \ no, Walk-in Closet \ yes, Water Source Type \ Community

      Room Types

      • Walk-in closet


      • Construction quality:
        Provided by the county assessor, this grade is based on a scale that varies by market. For more information, or to update the grade, contact the county assessor's office.
      • Exterior material: Wood
      • Room count: 6
      • Stories: 2
      • Structure type: Other


      • Floor size: 2,232 sqft
      • Last remodel year: 1998
      • Lot width: 183
      • Parcel #: 0700005000400013000
      • Zillow Home ID: 59664909

      Zestimate Details

      A Zestimate home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more

      The Value Range is the high and low estimate market value for which Zillow values a home. The more information, the smaller the range, and the more accurate the Zestimate. See data coverage and accuracy table

      Don't agree with your home's Zestimate? Owners can edit their home facts to make the Zestimate more accurate. Plus, you can leave an opinion on your Zestimate value below. Just click "Owner Estimate".
      +$5,305 Last 30 days
      Zestimate range
      Zestimate forecast
      One year
      To see Zestimate forecast
      Create a free account

      Popularity on Zillow

      If this home is listed on Zillow, it will reach the largest real estate network on the web.*
      3,843 all-time views
      of this home (chart)
      35 forecasted views of this home
      in the first 7 days after listing for sale
      Interested in selling this home?
      Post your home as Make Me Move, for sale, for rent, or contact an agent.

      Comparable Homes

      Homes like this sold for $505-860K.



      Home Expenses

      Internet, phone and TV
      Home security
      Home Insurance


      Market guide

      Zillow predicts Shelter Island Heights home values will decrease 0.1% next year, compared to a 0.8% rise for New York Metro as a whole. Among Shelter Island Heights homes, this home is valued 3.6% less than the midpoint (median) home, and is valued 15.4% less per square foot.

      Foreclosures will be a factor impacting home values in the next several years. In Shelter Island Heights, the number of foreclosures waiting to be sold is 38.9% less than in New York Metro, and 89.5% lower than the national average. This lower local number could help Shelter Island Heights home values rise more quickly than other regions in New York Metro.

      Learn more about forecast calculations or Shelter Island Heights home values.
        More Less 

        For Sale

        See all nearby listings


        See all nearby rentals

        Nearby Schools in Shelter Island Heights

        GreatSchools ratings give an overview of a school's test results. The ratings are based on a comparison of test results for all schools in the state.

        Disclaimer: School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics and are subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.

        Data by GreatSchools.org