Show:
Filter Save Search
Close

Get notifications of new listings in this region - save this search

A Rent Zestimate® is Zillow's estimated monthly rental price, computed using a proprietary formula. It is a starting point in determining the monthly rental price for a specific property. Learn more | Post a home for rent for FREE

A Zestimate® home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more | Post a home for sale for FREE

Make Me Move is a free and easy way to tell others the price you'd be willing to sell your home for.

This property is scheduled to be sold at a foreclosure auction. Learn more

The lender initiated foreclosure proceedings on these properties because the owners were in default on their loan obligations.

These properties are owned by a bank or a lender who took ownership through foreclosure proceedings. They may soon be listed for sale.

A Foreclosure Estimate is the price Zillow predicts a property will sell for if it's listed as a foreclosure (bank-owned property or real estate owned). Learn more

Town of Shelter Island Apartments for Rent

Loading results...

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$3,200/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $8,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
3
Baths:
1.5
Sqft:
1,496
Lot:
27,442
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1960
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
Just 1/10 of a mile to a beautiful Peconic Bay Beach, this meticulously maintained home offers an open kitchen, dining, and living room with fireplace. French doors open out to a deck overlooking the in-ground pool and beautifully landscaped yard. Water vi

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$34,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
4
Baths:
2.5
Sqft:
2,400
Lot:
37,461
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1985
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
Private Setting on a Freshwater Lake Yet Close to a Sandy Bay Beach. Large Deck for Endless Outdoor Entertainment. Swimming or Kayaking Right in Your Own Backyard.

6 Valley Rd, Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$20,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1960
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
This 1960'S Barn Has Been Renovated With A Contemporary Style. This Lovely Home Is In A Quiet Nbrhd, Great For The Summer With Your Own Gunite Pool. Hilo Dock To Board Your Boat In West Neck Harbor.Ely Flagstone Flooring On The First Floor And Wood Fl

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$30,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
--
Sqft:
1,584
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-High on a waterfront bluff with views to CT. New heated water side gunite pool, large and airy living space, CAC, spacious grounds with mature trees for privacy. July $30,000, August $35,000. (Listing 5380335 Confirmed 5/30/2013)

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$2,500/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
--
Sqft:
2,000
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-A beautifully kept 4BR, 2.5BA Contemporary on a cul-de-sac. So quiet you will hear the birds signing all the time. Nearby to Mashomack Preserve and Wades Beach. Perfect for families with an entertaining deck and patio, lots of patio doors to

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$30,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Farmhouse on the water with dock. 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, sleeping porch, LR, DR, eat in kitchen, and big yard for volleyball or relaxing. MD-LD $30,000. (Listing 5543570 Confirmed 5/30/2013)

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$4,500/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,500/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Located in an historic area sits a beautifully crafted Farmhouse with new addition. There are 4BRs and 2.5 Baths. Large chef's kitchen opens to dining room, with one of three fireplaces, that leads to back yard with heated gunite pool. M

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$2,600/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
3
Baths:
--
Sqft:
1,638
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-POOL HOUSEThis property could be your weekend sanctuary and summer retreat. Quiet street, multiple decks for entertaining, 3 bedroom , 2 baths, central air, outdoor shower and bath with private heated pool and garden. Memorial Day -Labor Day

24 Manwaring Rd, SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$27,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $7,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,689
Lot:
51,836
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1880
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
Rented For The 2012 Season. This 1880 Farmhouse Is Situated On 1.25 Acre Piece Of Property Across The Street From Sylvester Manor Preserve In The Center Of Shelter Island. Beaches Are Minutes Away. Weekly Rentals Are All Inclusive. Monthly Or Year Round,Ut

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$1,450/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
1
Baths:
--
Sqft:
9,000
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Renovated cottage with 1BR, 1BA with new kitchen, updated bath, flooring and freshly painted. Dining area, good storage, lawn maintenance and snow plowing included. $1,300 per month plus utilities. Laundry Room on premises. (Listing 5366528

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$7,500/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Cozy and sweet describes this 3BR, 2BA Arts & Crafts style house. Covered rocking chair porch, Dining Room, Living Room all surrounded by warm wood. Fresh vegetable garden to pick from and a studio if you need more room for guest. July $7,50

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$20,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $6,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
5
Baths:
--
Sqft:
1,733
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Large, open & airy with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths in main house with renovated kitchen and brand new guest cottage with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath and surfboard. Also heated pool, dock, beach and bird watching comes with this fabulous rental. 8/19

26 Lake Dr, , NY11964

 House For Rent:
$48,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $10,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
4
Baths:
4.0
Sqft:
1,897
Lot:
65,340
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
2000
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
Four bedroom/3.5-bath Contemporary on fresh pond. Elevated deck and patio for entertaining. Outdoor shower, kayaks, bikes, and wi-fi are a few of the amenities. An ideal summer rental on the pond and near Wades Beach.

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$8,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $6,500/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
2
Baths:
--
Sqft:
1,400
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND ARTSY HOUSE NEAR MASHOMACK PRESERVE Artsy, 2 bedroom ranch on 2 acres with huge lawn in back, perfect for privacy and outdoor parties. Land backs up to the 2000+ Mashomack Preserve and is within 1/2 mile of public trails. Art studio (with tw

(undisclosed Address), shelter island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$2,500/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $5,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
2
Baths:
1.0
Sqft:
854
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-Renovated summer cottage, perfect get a way. Deep water dock and able to hold several boats. Big yard for outside activities. MD-LD $25,000; June $5,000; July $9,000; August $11,000; last 2 weeks of August for $5,000. (Listing 5389428 Confir

15 Marc St, Shelter Island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$24,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $11,000/mo
Pets: --
Availability: now
Beds:
4
Baths:
3.0
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1980
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
Quiet dead-end road, centrally located, private fenced yard with built-in vinyl heated pool.

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$25,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $10,000/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
4
Baths:
--
Sqft:
2,632
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
The perfect late summer get away. The main house has 3BR and 2BA's, 2 LR's with fireplace set on a bluff with panoramic views of Gardiner's Bay The pool house has 1BR, 1BA, kitchen, and gathering area overlooking Gardiner's Bay with a lovel

(undisclosed Address), shelter island, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$10,000/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $6,500/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
1
Baths:
1.0
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
1880
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND-COTTAGE WITH SHARED POOLA sweet 1BR for 1 or a couple. Tucked behind private residence with shared pool. Close to South Ferry.MD-LD $10,000; June $3,000; July $3,500; August $4,500. (Listing 5690626 Confirmed 5/30/2013)

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

 House For Rent:
$1,800/mo
Rent Zestimate®: $4,995/mo
Pets: --
Beds:
2
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,200
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
15
Built:
--
Property type:
Single Family
Property Description:
SHELTER ISLAND - CREEKFRONT WITH DOCK Spacious, light filled and quiet area means this rental won't last long. Available Oct. 1 but call now to secure. Two large bedrooms with water views, eat in kitchen, laundry room and oversized Living Room with bri
Tip: save this search to get email alerts when listings hit the market.
  • Only showing 500 homes. Zoom in, or use filters to narrow your search.
View choices
No Street View available for this property.
       
      Go
    Home type
    Show only
  • Close
    Price
     
    Go
    Rent
     
    Go
    Beds
    Baths
    Square Feet
     
    Go
    Lot Size
     
    Go
    Year Built
     
    Go
    Days on/Sold in last
    Keywords
    Apply
Save this search and be notified when new listings are added.