Shelter Island Heights Real Estate & Shelter Island Heights NY Homes for Sale

1 Landing Ln, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $2,795,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 3.5
Sqft:: 2,000
Lot:: 44,431

Days on Zillow:: 2
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Beautifully and completely renovated 4 bedroom, 5 bath home on 1.2 acres in Hilo Shores area of Shelter Island with sunny Southern exposure, dock and pool. Featuring a spacious living room overlooking a large, covered, wrap deck and spectacular views of We

32 Hilo Dr, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $2,250,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 3.5
Sqft:: 2,237
Lot:: 43,560

Days on Zillow:: 57
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Enjoy this Hamptons-style cottage which sits high on a Shelter Island bluff, including a waterside heated pool and tennis court. House features a bright and sunny kitchen, large living room with French doors out to a covered veranda with views to die for,

12 Behringer Ln, SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $685,000

Beds:: 3
Baths:: 2.0
Sqft:: 2,008
Lot:: 21,780

Days on Zillow:: 60
Built:: 1989
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: This bright spacious island cottage near Crescent beach, golf and tennis awaits you with a beautifully landscaped yard and room for a pool. This home has 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, cathedral ceilings and natural sunlight throughout that makes this a sincerely we

(undisclosed Address)

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $910,000 +
Zestimate:: $778,354 and up
Parking:: No
Show 2 matching units

Beds:: 4+
Baths:: 3.0+
Sqft:: 2823+
Lot:: 40946

Days on Zillow:: 63
Built:: 1984

(undisclosed Address), Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $889,000

Beds:: 2
Baths:: 2.0
Sqft:: 1,600
Lot:: 34,848

Days on Zillow:: 65
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Located at the end of a quiet private road, this immaculate home is truly turnkey. Open living space with a large living room ,fireplace, eat-in-kitchen, modern kitchen with high end appliances, and lots of natural light, spa like master bathroom has Carre

2 Quail Hedge La, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $475,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 75
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Level acre by Heights and Gardiner's Creek. Convenient to all amenities.

2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $595,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 75
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Build your dream house on this wooded acre. Located in the upper reaches of the sought after Heights, this prime lot is near other attractive homes, yet very private with room for a pool. Within short distance to the Shelter Island Yacht Club, marinas, sho

(undisclosed Address), SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $445,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 77
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: This serene, slightly elevated .70 acre property, located in boating community with association dock access is ready for your Shelter Island home. Close proximity to Sunset Beach.

(undisclosed Address)

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $1,750,000 +
Parking:: No
Laundry:: Unknown
Show 2 matching units

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: 174240

Days on Zillow:: 107
Built:: --

148A N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $375,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 136
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Level one acre vacant lot has deeded water access to Gardiner's Creek. The property has a well in place and extensive walking paths have been cut so you can explore and envision building your dream house.

27 E Brander Pkwy, SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $735,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 2.0
Sqft:: 2,068
Lot:: 47,916

Days on Zillow:: 155
Built:: 2010
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: This modern unique 4 bedroom house is located in Silver Beach just a short distance to some of the most beautiful beaches Shelter Island has to offer. This open layout with center sunken pavilion features a large foyer, 4 bedrooms, 2 baths and an open layo

44 S Menantic Rd, SHELTER ISLAND, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $549,000

Beds:: 3
Baths:: 2.0
Sqft:: 1,900
Lot:: 41,817

Days on Zillow:: 155
Built:: 1975
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: M. Wein Realty, Inc

Property Description:: Beautiful property steps to marina and water. This cape offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, living room with fireplace, formal dining room, lots of sunlight. A two car garage, and opportunity for expansion, pool, tennis and/or guest house. EXCLUSIVE $549,000

7 Clinton Ave, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY11965

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $735,000

Beds:: 3
Baths:: 2.5
Sqft:: 1,799
Lot:: 10,890

Days on Zillow:: 158
Built:: 1890
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: M. Wein Realty, Inc

Property Description:: Lovingly maintained with original features, this circa 1890 Victorian sits on a quarter of an acre parcel with views over to the Shelter Yacht Club. Enjoy lazy afternoons and al fresco meals on the wrap around porch. Breakfast is served on the brick patio

33 Grand Ave, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY11965

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $835,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 3.0
Sqft:: 2,442
Lot:: 16,117

Days on Zillow:: 161
Built:: 1879
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: M. Wein Realty, Inc

Property Description:: Move right into this beautifully restored Heights Victorian circa 1879. Gracious details abound in this four bedroom, three bath treasure. Formal dining room with large alcove windows, gourmet eat-in-kitchen and family sitting room with brick patio just be

23 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $4,900,000

Beds:: 7
Baths:: 6.5
Sqft:: 4,302
Lot:: 56,627

Days on Zillow:: 168
Built:: 1981
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: M. Wein Realty, Inc

Property Description:: Unparalleled Dering Harbor Waterfront with panoramic views over the harbor and a 120' deep-water dock suited for 4 boats. This dock with cabana is undisputedly one of the best privately owned docks on the Island, having a depth of 6.5' at low tide. Shielde

9 Bay Shore Dr, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $995,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: 27,007

Days on Zillow:: 199
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: From 180 WOW ft. of water front, long distance vista across wide West Neck waters to Eastern shore of acres of wooded water front, plus all necessary permits for immediate build.

3 Primrose Pl, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $345,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 213
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Beautiful buildable acre convenient to Coecles Harbor, Gardiners Bay Country Club golf course, and several Shelter Island town beaches.

8 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $389,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Build your dream house on this beautiful wooded acre lot in the Hay Beach area of Shelter Island. Lovely in all seasons. Room for house, garage and pool. A short distance from several beautiful beaches and Gardiners Bay Country Club Golf Course. $100,000 +

2 Bonnie Ln, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $1,350,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 3.5
Sqft:: 2,953
Lot:: 82,764

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: This traditional style home is set on almost two acres of beautifully landscaped grounds. A welcoming covered entry porch greets you and leads you into the foyer. Beyond is the formal living room and a generously sized dining room for entertaining. The kit

151 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $1,900,000

Beds:: 6
Baths:: 3.5
Sqft:: 4,000
Lot:: 261,360

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Circa 1922, this historic stucco home with barrel tile roof sits off the road behind a large privet hedge. Set on 6 acres of wooded land, this large 6 bedroom, completely renovated home also boasts a large 2 story barn with full bath and 3 car garage. Meti

3 Hay Beach Rd, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $849,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 2.5
Sqft:: 2,293
Lot:: 43,560

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: On a beautiful acre near beaches and Gardiners Bay Country Club golf course, this spacious 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers a living room with fireplace, formal dining room with access to a backyard deck blooming with lilacs, eat-in-kitchen, huge master sui

14 Cozy Ln, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $510,000

Beds:: 3
Baths:: 1.0
Sqft:: 1,000
Lot:: 43,560

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: On a lovely expansive acre with a great yard, this 3 bedroom home is located in the Silver Beach area of Shelter Island near beaches and boating. This newly shingle home features 3 bedrooms, new tiled bath, living room with wood stove, dining room, eat-in-

1 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $1,250,000

Beds:: 4
Baths:: 4.0
Sqft:: 2,187
Lot:: 47,916

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: There are places on Shelter Island where we dream of living but this is one that can be yours. A wonderfully comfortable home visually connected to Peconic Bay and the Sound. Comfortable, relaxing and only 100 miles from busy Manhattan. Welcome to the livi

13 Petticoat Ln, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

House For Sale:: $575,000

Beds:: 3
Baths:: 2.0
Sqft:: 1,457
Lot:: 37,026

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Single Family
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Enjoy this extremely well maintained cottage located on a lovely tree lined parcel of land. This 3 bedroom 2 bath home features a huge 24ft.x24ft master bedroom suite with large bathroom including a garden tub and separate shower. This is a terrific starte

11 Serpentine Dr, Shelter Island, NY11964

Featured Listing

Lot/Land For Sale:: $8,250,000

Beds:: --
Baths:: --
Sqft:: --
Lot:: --

Days on Zillow:: 225
Built:: --
Property type:: Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:: The Corcoran Group

Property Description:: Nearly 11 acres and 630 feet of sandy beachfront with glorious sunset views and grandfathered sea plane pad. Located in sought-after area with beautiful elevations and thresholds to accommodate a grand estate home. Only acreage of this kind available on Sh

Get notifications of new listings in this region - save this search

Shelter Island Heights Real Estate