Show:
Filter Save Search
Close

Get notifications of new listings in this region - save this search

A Rent Zestimate® is Zillow's estimated monthly rental price, computed using a proprietary formula. It is a starting point in determining the monthly rental price for a specific property. Learn more | Post a home for rent for FREE

A Zestimate® home valuation is Zillow's estimated market value. It is not an appraisal. Use it as a starting point to determine a home's value. Learn more | Post a home for sale for FREE

Make Me Move is a free and easy way to tell others the price you'd be willing to sell your home for.

This property is scheduled to be sold at a foreclosure auction. Learn more

The lender initiated foreclosure proceedings on these properties because the owners were in default on their loan obligations.

These properties are owned by a bank or a lender who took ownership through foreclosure proceedings. They may soon be listed for sale.

A Foreclosure Estimate is the price Zillow predicts a property will sell for if it's listed as a foreclosure (bank-owned property or real estate owned). Learn more

Kelleys Island Real Estate

Loading results...

417 Sweetvalley Ln, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 For Sale by Owner:
$395,000
Zestimate®: $335,750
Est. Mortgage: $1,788/mo
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.5
Sqft:
1,892
Lot:
24,829
Days on Zillow:
5
Built:
1997
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Custom built home, centrally located on one of Lake Erie's premier island destinations. Situated halfway between downtown and Kelley's Island State park and pristine beach, Sweetvalley Estates is a quiet neighborhood tucked back off the main drag. Home fea

803 E Lakeshore, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$369,000
Zestimate®: $313,650
Est. Mortgage: $1,670/mo
Beds:
3
Baths:
1.5
Sqft:
1,152
Lot:
13,111
Days on Zillow:
6
Built:
1983
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Lowest priced Lakefront home on Kelleys Island. 3 Bedroom 1.5 bath. Cottage faces south towards Cedar Point and Marblehead.Updates include 30yr shingles on new roof in 2005,H2O tank replaced in 2007, septic tank pumped in 2010. Priced to sell!

111 W Lakeshore # 1F, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Condo For Sale:
$234,900
Zestimate®: $199,665
Est. Mortgage: $1,063/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,100
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
12
Built:
1990
Property type:
Condo
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Lowest priced end unit. Lakeview. Master bedroom on first floor. This unit can function as a 3 bedroom. Unit is directly across from pool and just a few steps from downtown area.

111 W Lakeshore # 5B, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Condo For Sale:
$197,500
Zestimate®: $171,143
Est. Mortgage: $894/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,080
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
12
Built:
1993
Property type:
Condo
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Lowest priced condo! Pond view. First floor unit. Walk off deck, ground level unit allows for propane grill. Newly remodeled in 2012. Furnishings to transfer, all tenants to transfer.

306 Lower Cliff Dr, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$217,000
Zestimate®: $181,035
Est. Mortgage: $982/mo
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,164
Lot:
11,979
Days on Zillow:
13
Built:
1995
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Fireplace, Jacuzzi In Mbr, Hot-Tub, Positive Income, 10Ft X 16Ft Barn, Quarry Vista Lodge And Home In Excellent Condition With New Flooring, On 2 Lots In Desirable Investment Area, Pella, Air Conditioning, Quality & Comfort Abounds! Positive Rental Income

122 Southaven, KELLEYS ISLAND, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$319,000
Est. Mortgage: $1,444/mo
Beds:
3
Baths:
4.0
Sqft:
2,250
Lot:
19,602
Days on Zillow:
17
Built:
2002
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
CENTURY 21 DePiero ...
Property Description:
Custom Built Island Home with peeks of the lake and beach priviledges on quiet cul-de-sac street!!Two first floor master suites with full glamour baths!!Large 2nd floor dormer with a full bath and walk in closet!!Vaulted Ceilings with skylites gives the ho

E Lake Shr, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$389,000
Est. Mortgage: $1,761/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
43,000
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
22
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
Coldwell Banker Rou...
Property Description:
East Lake Shore & Addison, Irregular Shaped Lot close to Ferrys Downtown Lake View

108 Southaven Ln, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$229,900
Zestimate®: $193,101
Est. Mortgage: $1,041/mo
Open house:
Sat. 12-2pm
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,444
Lot:
20,037
Days on Zillow:
26
Built:
1999
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Kelleys Island Home Built In 1999 Featuring 3 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, Central Hvac, City Water And An Attached Garage. The Property Is Located In The Southaven Subdivision And Is Only About 700 Feet From The Lake. Relax And Enjoy The Lake View From The Fro

E Lakeshore, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$369,000
Zestimate®: --
Est. Mortgage: $1,670/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
43,124
Days on Zillow:
26
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Fully Wooded Lakefront Lot On Southeast Corner Of Island. Build Your Own Dream House Today!

111 W Lakeshore Dr # 9F, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$239,900
Zestimate®: $191,054
Est. Mortgage: $1,086/mo
Open house:
Sat. 12-2pm
Beds:
3
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,400
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
28
Built:
1996
Property type:
Townhouse
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Kelleys Island Condo - End Unit. 3 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, Appliances And Furniture Stay! Income Potential Approximately $10K - 15K A Year. A Great Location On Kelleys Island,Just A Short Walk To Ferry's, Downtown, Businesses And Marinas.

Maryann, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$850,000
Zestimate®: --
Est. Mortgage: $3,848/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
566,280
Days on Zillow:
33
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
Howard Hanna
Property Description:
This 4 parcel package includes parcel id 54-00181-000 54-00182-000 54-00183-000 54-00184-000 and is not dividable On Streets Lentz, Maryann and Oak. This UNIQUE 13 acre parcel has approximately 700 feet of water frontage, some is partially wooded AND is lo

111 W Lakeshore Dr # 8C, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$234,900
Zestimate®: $199,541
Est. Mortgage: $1,063/mo
Open house:
Sat. 12-2pm
Beds:
3
Baths:
3.0
Sqft:
1,330
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
34
Built:
1995
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
This Kelleys Island Condo Has 3 Bedrooms & 3 Full Baths! Move In Ready For You And Your Family Or Great As A Rental. It's A Second Floor Unit With A Loft, Covered Deck, Kitchen Appliances, Washer & Dryer And The Furniture Can Stay!

46-48 Beech, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$39,000
Zestimate®: --
Est. Mortgage: $177/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
14,374
Days on Zillow:
36
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
Remax Lake Shore Re...
Property Description:
For more information on this property, contact the listing agents Gary and Peg hopp at 419-270-3800 or garyhopp@hoppservices.com. This is 2 lots combined for you to install your well and septic as you build your island cottage. These lots are not on the wa

223 Lower Clf, KELLEYS ISLAND, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$194,900
Price Cut: $4,100(May 13)
Zestimate®: $157,435
Est. Mortgage: $882/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
1.0
Sqft:
1,191
Lot:
5,532
Days on Zillow:
43
Built:
2001
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Well maintained 2 bedroom 1 bath located near inland quarry off Bookerman Rd. New metal roof in 2012. Motivated sellers!!

340 Beach, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$600,000
Zestimate®: $519,136
Est. Mortgage: $2,716/mo
Beds:
4
Baths:
4.0
Sqft:
3,542
Lot:
5,837
Days on Zillow:
43
Built:
2005
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
This 4 bedroom is laid out for island life and relaxation! Ground level consists of a game room with wet bar, full bath, utility room and poker room. The mid level features kitchen, living room, master, bedroom 2 and family theater. 3rd level contains 2 ad

303 Woodford Dr, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$199,999
Price Cut: $19,901(Apr 3)
Zestimate®: $192,934
Est. Mortgage: $905/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
69
Built:
--
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:

303 Woodford, KELLYS ISLAND, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$199,999
Price Cut: $19,901(Apr 3)
Zestimate®: $173,622
Est. Mortgage: $905/mo
Beds:
6
Baths:
1.0
Sqft:
1,968
Lot:
20,124
Days on Zillow:
71
Built:
1888
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Built in 1888 this 6 bedroom farm house is conveniently located within walking distance to Kelleys Island ferry boat, the downtown area, ball park, recreation area and winery.. The house sits on 144.5x269 Ft lot (.92 acres) 16x14 shed attached. Call today

0 Southaven, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$55,000
Zestimate®: --
Est. Mortgage: $249/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
18,992
Days on Zillow:
99
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
Remax Beyond 2000 R...
Property Description:
Build your island dream home in this great subdivision on island's south side. Over 400 feet Lake Erie beach front rights.

0 Pike Lots 6 # 7, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Lot/Land For Sale:
$16,000
Zestimate®: --
Est. Mortgage: $72/mo
Beds:
--
Baths:
--
Sqft:
--
Lot:
10,890
Days on Zillow:
101
Built:
--
Property type:
Vacant Land
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Kelleys Island Lots: 55 X 91 And 55 X 103 Totaling Approximately .25 Acre. These Two Lots Are Situated Just West of Division St. Near Downtown Kelleys Island, Right Behind 231 & 235 Division St. The Legal Access Road Has Never Been Put In(See Aerial Photo

111 W Lakeshore Unit: # 1F, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$234,900
Zestimate®: $207,613
Est. Mortgage: $1,063/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,100
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
112
Built:
1990
Property type:
Townhouse
Brokerage Name:
Remax Beyond 2000 R...
Property Description:
Lowest priced end unit. Lakeview. Master bedroom on first floor. This unit can function as a 3 bedroom. Unit is directly across from pool and just a few steps from downtown area.

111 W Lakeshore Unit: # 5B, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 Condo For Sale:
$197,500
Zestimate®: $179,775
Est. Mortgage: $894/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
2.0
Sqft:
1,080
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
112
Built:
1993
Property type:
Condo
Brokerage Name:
Remax Beyond 2000 R...
Property Description:
Lowest priced condo! Pond view. First floor unit. Walk off deck, ground level unit allows for propane grill. Newly remodeled in 2012. Furnishings to transfer, all tenants to transfer.

305 Lower Cliff Dr, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$227,000
Price Cut: $2,000(Apr 16)
Zestimate®: $191,942
Est. Mortgage: $1,028/mo
Beds:
3
Baths:
1.5
Sqft:
1,120
Lot:
17,728
Days on Zillow:
122
Built:
2002
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
Property Description:
Positive Income! Lower Cliff Lodge And Home On Kelleys Island On 3 Lots With 30X56 Foot Pole Barn That Is Custom Built & Commercial Grade! Excellent Condition, A Young 2002 With Positive Rental Income Since Then. Air Conditioning, Fully Furnished If Desire

114 Martin Ln, Kelleys Island, OH43438

 House For Sale:
$524,999
Price Cut: $50,001(Apr 18)
Zestimate®: $497,928
Est. Mortgage: $2,377/mo
Beds:
2
Baths:
1.5
Sqft:
1,400
Lot:
--
Days on Zillow:
130
Built:
1950
Property type:
Single Family
Brokerage Name:
RE/MAX BEYOND 2000
Property Description:
Sightlines that have to be seen to believe. Deep water on eastern side of the island.
Tip: save this search to get email alerts when listings hit the market.
Close
Premier Agents What's this?
Close

Premier Agents are local, knowledgeable real estate professionals ready to help you find or sell the perfect home.

Are you an agent? To learn how to appear here, contact us at 866-324-4005.

  • Only showing 500 homes. Zoom in, or use filters to narrow your search.
View choices
No Street View available for this property.
       
      Go
    Home type
    Show only
  • Close
    Price
     
    Go
    Rent
     
    Go
    Beds
    Baths
    Square Feet
     
    Go
    Lot Size
     
    Go
    Year Built
     
    Go
    Days on/Sold in last
    Keywords
    Apply
Save this search and be notified when new listings are added.