Profile picture for Jay Baumgartner

Jay Baumgartner

Zillow All Star

The All-Star badge is given to top contributors of the Zillow community. These are active Zillow users who share their real estate knowledge and help others by contributing high-quality content. The more and better the contributions, the more likely an award will be granted. Users' contributions can be seen in their profiles.

Premier AgentTeam

52 Recent Sales (last 12 months)

The Baumgartner Group (14 years experience)

Specialties:
Buyer's Agent,
Listing Agent,
Relocation

Add personality to your profile! Tell the community about yourself, your home, and your profession.

-Career sales in excess of $300 Milllion
-More than 50 years of combined Real Estate experience
-More than $14 million in sales for 2014 - a home sold every 6 days!
-#7 company-wide for homes sold in 2014 (over 1,000 agents)
-#7 company-wide for total sales in 2014 (over 1,000 agents) 
- #1 in the New Berlin Office for 9 consecutive years in both total Sales and Units
-Top 1% of all Metro-Milwaukee MLS Realtors®
-Top 1% Nationally
-Associate Vice President
-President's Club Member
-Featured Annually in Milwaukee Magazine's Five Star: Best in Client Satisfaction issue

Jay Baumgartner has more than 13 years selling residential real estate, and graduated from the Business School at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Sara Baumgartner has more than 13 years selling residential real estate, and graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

Julie Baumgartner has more than 30 years selling residential real estate in the Metro-Milwaukee and surrounding areas.

More Less 
About Jay Baumgartner: -Career sales in excess of $300 Milllion <br/> -More than 50 years of combined Real Estate experience <br/> -More than $14 million in sales for 2014 - a home sold every 6 days! <br/> -#7 company-wide for homes sold in 2014 (over 1,000 agents) <br/> -#7 company-wide for total sales in 2014 (over 1,000 agents)&nbsp; <br/>- #1 in the New Berlin Office for 9 consecutive years in both total Sales and Units <br/> -Top 1% of all Metro-Milwaukee MLS Realtors&reg; <br/> -Top 1% Nationally <br/>-Associate Vice President <br/> -President's Club Member <br/> -Featured Annually in Milwaukee Magazine's Five Star: Best in Client Satisfaction issue <p>&bull;<strong>Jay Baumgartner&nbsp;</strong>has more than 13 years selling residential real estate,&nbsp;and graduated from the Business School at the University of&nbsp;Wisconsin-Madison.<br/><br/>&bull;<strong>Sara Baumgartner</strong>&nbsp;has more than 13 years selling residential real estate,&nbsp;and graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.<br/><br/>&bull;<strong>Julie Baumgartner</strong> has more than 30 years selling residential real estate in the Metro-Milwaukee and surrounding areas.</p>

Listings & Sales  

  • For Sale
  • For Rent
  • Sold

Active Listings  

(20)
Property Address
Bed / Bath
Price

Past Sales  

(162 all-time)
Property Address
Represented
Sold Date
Price
Seller
03/04/2015
$73,900

Report a problem with the transaction

03/04/2015 - Seller - $73,900

Please enter a valid email address.

Transaction flagged

We will review this transaction. If changes are necessary, it may take up to 2 weeks for corrections to appear on Zillow. Thanks for helping make the site more useful to everyone. To learn more, read Zillow's Good Neighbor Policy.

We're sorry. This service is temporarily unavailable. Please come back later and try again.

Seller
03/02/2015
$100,000

Report a problem with the transaction

03/02/2015 - Seller - $100,000

Please enter a valid email address.

Transaction flagged

We will review this transaction. If changes are necessary, it may take up to 2 weeks for corrections to appear on Zillow. Thanks for helping make the site more useful to everyone. To learn more, read Zillow's Good Neighbor Policy.

We're sorry. This service is temporarily unavailable. Please come back later and try again.

Seller
01/19/2015
$190,500

Report a problem with the transaction

01/19/2015 - Seller - $190,500

Please enter a valid email address.

Transaction flagged

We will review this transaction. If changes are necessary, it may take up to 2 weeks for corrections to appear on Zillow. Thanks for helping make the site more useful to everyone. To learn more, read Zillow's Good Neighbor Policy.

We're sorry. This service is temporarily unavailable. Please come back later and try again.

Seller
01/08/2015
$249,500

Report a problem with the transaction

01/08/2015 - Seller - $249,500

Please enter a valid email address.

Transaction flagged

We will review this transaction. If changes are necessary, it may take up to 2 weeks for corrections to appear on Zillow. Thanks for helping make the site more useful to everyone. To learn more, read Zillow's Good Neighbor Policy.

We're sorry. This service is temporarily unavailable. Please come back later and try again.

Buyer
12/30/2014
$254,000

Report a problem with the transaction

12/30/2014 - Buyer - $254,000

Please enter a valid email address.

Transaction flagged

We will review this transaction. If changes are necessary, it may take up to 2 weeks for corrections to appear on Zillow. Thanks for helping make the site more useful to everyone. To learn more, read Zillow's Good Neighbor Policy.

We're sorry. This service is temporarily unavailable. Please come back later and try again.

Team reviews

Jay was incredible to work with, particularly given the circumstances. My parents passed away recently, and I was tasked with getting my childhood home ready to sell...at a distance. I live 90 miles away and the house required basement work and multiple updates before I felt ready to sell it. The basement contractor recommended Jay, and from the moment I met him, I knew he and his team were going to do a fabulous, competent job for me. He listened, cared, and was reasonable with me when I was hovering close to some very real and difficult emotions, talking me through the "letting go" transition in a very professional manner. I felt understood and respected through the whole process and can't imagine anyone else doing as spectacular a job as he did. He kept me informed of showings and eventually the offer. He worked with me on pricing strategies and making sure the house looked good throughout. AT the closing, he spent time with me and made sure I was comfortable through the documentation signing. I can't say enough about Jay, his character, and real estate expertise. Jay and the Baumgartner Group are great!!

  

02/05/2015 - Fresca1990
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 in Wauwatosa, WI.

Jay was incredible to work with, particularly given the circumstances. My parents passed away recently, and I was tasked with getting my childhood home ready to sell...at a distance. I live 90 miles away and the house required basement work and multiple updates before I felt ready to sell it. The basement contractor recommended Jay, and from the moment I met him, I knew he and his team were going to do a fabulous, competent job for me. He listened, cared, and was reasonable with me when I was hovering close to some very real and difficult emotions, talking me through the "letting go" transition in a very professional manner. I felt understood and respected through the whole process and can't imagine anyone else doing as spectacular a job as he did. He kept me informed of showings and eventually the offer. He worked with me on pricing strategies and making sure the house looked good throughout. AT the closing, he spent time with me and made sure I was comfortable through the documentation signing. I can't say enough about Jay, his character, and real estate expertise. Jay and the Baumgartner Group are great!!  More Less 

Profile picture for Jay Baumgartner
Response from Jay

 

  

02/05/2015 - emelka
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 in Waukesha, WI.

Jay did an excellant job representing me during my house selling process. He was very knowledgeable with the current real estate markets and areas which helped me decide on a good selling price. He was very professional and was very responsive to my questions during the process. His feeback and follow up on all showings was very valuable to me. His negotiation skills were very good which was helpful in dealing with offers. All in all he did a great job for me and I would recommend him to someone else who is selling their property.  More Less 

Profile picture for Jay Baumgartner
Response from Jay

 

  

01/16/2015 - mavtcb
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 for approximately $275K in Oak Creek, WI.

I cannot say enough fantastic things about Jay. He answered all of my questions with patience and professionalism. He always responded quickly to all of our emails and was on top of everything we needed for both selling our home and purchasing a new one. Even with two of us working full-time it was very easy to schedule showings with him. With selling our home he helped us determine a fair price and explained how he came up with the numbers. He gave suggestions on decluttering and his photographer took amazing pictures that really helped sell our home. With purchasing a new home he was very patient and took us to see over 100 homes and we never felt pressure to buy something. He always went above and beyond to make sure we were 100% happy.  More Less 

Profile picture for Jay Baumgartner
Response from Jay

 

Service Areas