Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal

Stephanie Rosenthal

Zillow All Star

The All-Star badge is given to top contributors of the Zillow community. These are active Zillow users who share their real estate knowledge and help others by contributing high-quality content. The more and better the contributions, the more likely an award will be granted. Users' contributions can be seen in their profiles.

Premier Agent

26 Recent Sales (last 12 months)

Real Estate Professional

Specialties:
Buyer's Agent,
Listing Agent,
Relocation,
Short-Sale

Ratings & Reviews

When I recently decided to downsize and sell my home I researched several real estate agents. I made my decision to go with Stephanie, and I must say it has proved to be one of the best business decisions I have made in my entire life. She is truly professional and knowledgeable in her field. She has been by my side every step of the way. From the moment I signed the contract to closing. She always made herself available to me with any questions I may have had( and yes I had plenty) and she always addressed them with sound honest advice. Her expertise in the industry helped sell my home quickly. Her hard work ethics and dedication is outstanding. It’s obvious she has a passion and love for what she does for a living every day because she does it so well. I would highly recommend Stephanie to anyone whether buying or selling a home. Diane Bethell

  

01/31/2015 - dianebethell
Sold a Single Family home in 2015 for approximately $400K in New Dorp Beach, Staten Island, NY.

When I recently decided to downsize and sell my home I researched several real estate agents. I made my decision to go with Stephanie, and I must say it has proved to be one of the best business decisions I have made in my entire life. She is truly professional and knowledgeable in her field. She has been by my side every step of the way. From the moment I signed the contract to closing. She always made herself available to me with any questions I may have had( and yes I had plenty) and she always addressed them with sound honest advice. Her expertise in the industry helped sell my home quickly. Her hard work ethics and dedication is outstanding. It’s obvious she has a passion and love for what she does for a living every day because she does it so well. I would highly recommend Stephanie to anyone whether buying or selling a home. Diane Bethell

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie on 03/16/2015

Dear Diane, Thank you so much for your review. I am so glad we had the opportunity to work together. I love the business that I am in because I get to meet terrific people like you and your family. Looking forward to working with your friends and family in the future! Sincerely, Stephanie

 

  

01/26/2015 - x37y
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 for approximately $450K in Bay Terrace, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie was a phenomenal agent! My father passed away suddenly and I had to sell the family home. I live out of town and so I identified agents from Zillow with homes for sale in the area of the family home. I phone screened them and then settled on three to meet in person. Selling a home is stressful; doing it from a distance compounds that stress. Stephanie was the only agent who came to the interview with all the items I had requested, even though she was on vacation when I initially contacted her and didn't get back into town until the day before the interview. She also had analyzed the property and did a market analysis so that when we met, she had a justified price point already in mind (nb - it was almost exactly what a private, 3rd party assessor I contracted assigned the house value). She answered all my questions and went out of her way to assure me she would take care of everything. I followed my gut and chose her, even though one of the other agents appeared more "smooth". I was not disappointed. She personally cleaned my parents' home and staged it so that the online photos were beautiful! She then advertised it and did the open house. She anticipated multiple offers, which we received in a 3 day period! She negotiated the offers and we got our asking price! She helped me obtain an attorney and complete all the other work needed to sell the property, including coming over to help empty the house the week before the sale and loaning me her vacuum to clean it! Throughout the entire process, Stephanie was available by phone and text. She was highly responsive to any requests I made, she was fully knowledgeable about the sale process from start to finish (and when she couldn't answer one question, she researched it and got back to me within a day). She fully negotiated everything on my behalf. Stephanie told me she would do whatever it takes to make a sale - and she did, in a highly professional manner. I fully recommend her if you want to sell a house and know that your agent is not only knowledgeable and professional, but will also go the extra mile to get your house sold.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie

 

  

12/11/2014 - s4jk17
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 for approximately $475K in Woodrow, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie was very professional. Sold my home quickly and got me the price I was looking for. Also helpful with anything else I needed. Would highly recommend her to anyone who is selling their home.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie on 03/16/2015

Thank you so much for your review. It was a pleasure working with you. I am glad you are happy in your new home in Florida.

 

  

12/11/2014 - suek236
Sold a Single Family home in 2014 for approximately $475K in Woodrow, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie was very professional and and curtious. She sold my home quickly and alo got me the price I was looking to get. She was also very helpful with everything else that I needed. I would highly recommend her to anyone selling their home.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie

 

  

12/05/2014 - barbarajean1209
Bought a Single Family home in 2014 in Greenridge, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie is an extremely professional and knowledgeable agent. No matter who she is working for- the buyer or the seller- she is 100% invested in getting you what you want. She pulls out all the stops. What I found most impressive about Stephanie is her honesty and integrity. I recommend her with no reservations.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie on 03/16/2015

Dear Barbara, Thank you for your review I enjoyed our time together looking for homes and getting to know you. Sincerely, Stephanie

 

  

11/20/2014 - user42388702
Bought a Single Family home in 2014 for approximately $300K in Elm Park, Staten Island, NY.

We really enjoy our time with Stephanie. She is honest and made herself available to show us homes on our shedule. We felt comfortable with her and knew she was there to work for us. I highly recommend her.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie on 03/16/2015

Thank you for your review. I loved working with you guys. We for sure had a lot of laughs. You both were very loyal clients and look forward to working with you in the future. Sincerely, Stephanie

 

  

10/09/2014 - taraenotaro
Sold a home in 2014.

Selling a home is a stressful situation. Having Stephanie guide me through this process made it so much easier! She was courteous and professional right up to and including the closing. She is a broker I would highly recommend.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie

 

  

09/15/2014 - roebonagura
Sold a Multi Family home in 2012 for approximately $400K in Rosebank, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie Rosenthal was not only my realtor but my friend. I knew she would do right by me and as soon as she came for her initial meeting and walk-through, I felt confident that she was going to be the right match to not only sell my two family house but to find the condo I wanted to downsize to. She went through every room in my apartment first, making suggestions and notations on a legal pad. I respected these suggestions, which included her excellent decorating experience, and put the plan into effect immediately. Long story short, the house was sold in less than two months from the open house. Stephanie has such a great personality, is very positive, uplifting, reassuring and confident. It’s no wonder she’s so successful. Stephanie also took me to many condo’s in the meantime to see what I liked and would make me happy, I initially wanted a two bedroom but soon realized that that the one bedroom was all I needed. Stephanie’s patience during this transition was astounding. I kept changing my mind but she kept pushing forward with her patience and understanding and helped me make my final decision. I am so happy in my little condo by the mall. I can’t thank Stephanie enough. She somehow new what would be a perfect home for me of which I am truly appreciative. I recommend her highly whether you are looking to buy or sell. You couldn’t find a smarter “cookie” than Steph and that’s not because she’s my friend but because she delivers.,

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie

 

  

08/27/2014 - enoka nanayakkara
Sold a Single Family home in 2012 in Grant City, Staten Island, NY.

Stephanie Rosenthal is an excellent extremely knowledgeable realtor on Staten Island. Stephanie is the hardest working real estate person that I have ever encountered. I've had dealings with many other real estate professionals and I must say that Stephanie's efforts and professionalism far exceeded all others. She was extremely proficient and professional in the process of the sale of our home. She listens to your needs and concerns and was always available 24-7 throughout the entire process. She even left her July 4th BBQ and her guests when she received a call for a showing of my house. Her professional approach to selling your home, her real estate knowledge and expertise is second to none. Stephanie shows and displays superb knowledge of the trade and an intense dedication to the task at hand. I highly recommend her as a realtor to anyone interested in Buying/Selling/Renting or anything Real Estate. I can't stress enough that I would use her again and again.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie

 

  

08/27/2014 - sanjidunu
Sold a home in 2010 in Eltingville, Staten Island, New York, NY 10312.

Stephanie is very knowledgeable and extremely accommodating person to your needs when it comes to selling your house. She sold our house in Colfax Ave Staten Island in the Midland Ave area. Stephanie takes a personal interest in your home and stage the house well according to your style and to attract the prospective buyers and clients. We had a great experience selling our home with Stephanie. She is not only our realtor for life but also our newly found best friend to me and my family. We highly recommend Stephanie Rosenthal as your real estate agent.

Profile picture for Stephanie Rosenthal
Response from Stephanie