523 E College St, Broken Arrow, OK 74012

Two Homes in One Crafted for seamless multi-generational living or turnkey rental income, the property features two fully independent residences—each with its own garage, dedicated HVAC zones, and tankless water heater. Professionally insulated between units for temperature regulation and soundproofing, both homes maintain privacy and comfort. The private apartment is currently leased, generating immediate cash flow. Please allow 24-hour notice for showings out of respect for current tenants. Private Apartment / Mother-in-Law Suite • Fully furnished turnkey suite, including furniture and in-unit washer/dryer • Private ground-level patio for morning coffee or evening relaxation • Full kitchen with granite countertops and stainless steel appliances • Accessible curbless walk-in shower with built-in bench and dual showerheads • Main-level bedroom and bath, plus upstairs loft/office, second bedroom, and full bath • Oversized single-car garage with built-in storage • Configured now as 1 bed/1 bath, but easily converted to 2 beds/2 baths • Features a wood wall reclaimed from a family barn Main House Showpiece • Grand 20×40 great room with acoustic paneling, rock fireplace, exposed beams, and soaring 20-ft vaulted ceilings • Hand-sewn pecan mantle above the fireplace, milled from the original on-site tree • Quartz countertops throughout, including chef’s kitchen with 36" 6-burner gas range • Main-floor primary suite with spa-inspired bath, dual vanities, and walk-in closet • Private office with en-suite bath and exposed brick wall salvaged from the original home • Dedicated theater room for cinematic movie nights • Workshop space perfect for DIY projects, tinkering, and crafts • Two walk-in pantries plus a large utility room featuring a built-in dog wash and laundry chute • Two covered front porches for indoor-outdoor living • Upper level hosts two bedrooms, full bath, game room, and large deck overlooking the backyard and firepit • Expansive backyard—room for a pool, garden, or play area • 20×30 unfinished attic space for future expansion or hobby studio • Two-car garage with abundant storage Premium Features & Provenance • Three high-efficiency Trane HVAC systems for personalized comfort year-round • Two tankless water heaters delivering endless hot water • Solid white oak hardwood floors throughout • Top-tier appliances and custom built-in cabinetry (so much storage everywhere!) • Covered parking for three vehicles plus ample guest parking • Per courthouse records, the home is listed at 5,715 sq ft Historical Significance The original home on this site was once the residence of the first president of Haskell State College and later served as a women’s dormitory for the school. Its legacy lives on through the reclaimed brick wall in the office and the pecan mantles—blending heritage with modern luxury. Whether you’re seeking a private sanctuary, a turnkey rental suite, or a grand statement home with room to grow, this Rose District masterpiece delivers unmatched luxury, versatility, and story-rich character. >>Realtors welcome.