Location at it's best.
This Whitefish Bay Property offers townhomes, and 2-bedroom apartments close to shopping and local activities.
Bay Colony I
189-203 E Fairmount Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Apartment building
2 beds
Pet-friendly
Surface parking lot
In-unit laundry (W/D)
Available units
Price may not include required fees and charges
Price may not include required fees and charges.
Unit , sortable column | Sqft, sortable column | Available, sortable column | Base rent, sorted ascending |
|---|---|---|---|
 | 850 | Dec 15 | $985 |
What's special
Office hours
| Day | Open hours |
|---|---|
| Mon - Fri: | By appointment only |
| Sat: | Closed |
| Sun: | Closed |
Facts, features & policies
Building Amenities
Other
- In Unit: Coin Operating Washer/Dryer
Services & facilities
- On-Site Maintenance
Unit Features
Appliances
- Dryer: Coin Operating Washer/Dryer
- Washer: Coin Operating Washer/Dryer
Policies
Parking
- Off Street Parking: Parking Lot Parking.
Lease terms
- Available months 12
Pet essentials
- CatsAllowedNumber allowed2Weight limit (lbs.)25Monthly cat rent$50Cat deposit$250
Restrictions
Please call our Leasing Office for complete Pet Policy information.
Neighborhood: 53217
- Family VibesWarm atmosphere with family-friendly amenities and safe, welcoming streets.Beach AccessEasy coastal access for swimming, sunbathing, and seaside relaxation.Green SpacesScenic trails and gardens with private, less-crowded natural escapes.Dining SceneFrom casual bites to fine dining, a haven for food lovers.
The North Shore’s 53217—covering Whitefish Bay, Fox Point, Bayside, River Hills, and parts of Glendale—blends lakeside calm with everyday convenience. Expect four true seasons (snowy winters, cool Lake Michigan summers), walkable, tree-lined streets, and a community-forward rhythm. Outdoorsy days mean beach time at Klode Park and Doctors Park, ravine walks at Big Bay Park, birding at Schlitz Audubon Nature Center, and artful strolls at Lynden Sculpture Garden, with the Oak Leaf Trail threading through. Daily needs and treats are close at hand on Silver Spring Drive and at Bayshore Town Center, home to Trader Joe’s, Sendik’s, Metro Market, Colectivo Coffee, boutiques, and fitness spots like Wisconsin Athletic Club and Orangetheory, plus a broad dining scene from casual patios to polished sit-downs. I‑43 offers quick downtown access. According to Zillow Market Trends from recent months, median asking rent is around $2,000, with most rentals ranging roughly $1,500–$3,000 depending on size and proximity to the lake. Pet-friendly parks and quiet blocks suit strollers and leashes alike.
Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Nearby schools in Whitefish Bay
GreatSchools rating
- 10/10Cumberland Elementary SchoolGrades: PK-5Distance: 0.7 mi
- 10/10Whitefish Bay Middle SchoolGrades: 6-8Distance: 0.7 mi
- 10/10Whitefish Bay High SchoolGrades: 9-12Distance: 1.2 mi
Frequently asked questions
What is the walk score of Bay Colony I?
Bay Colony I has a walk score of 39, it's car-dependent.
What schools are assigned to Bay Colony I?
The schools assigned to Bay Colony I include Cumberland Elementary School, Whitefish Bay Middle School, and Whitefish Bay High School.
Does Bay Colony I have in-unit laundry?
Yes, Bay Colony I has in-unit laundry for some or all of the units.
What neighborhood is Bay Colony I in?
Bay Colony I is in the 53217 neighborhood in Whitefish Bay, WI.
What are Bay Colony I's policies on pets?
Cats are allowed, with a maximum weight restriction of 25lbs. A maximum of 2 cats are allowed per unit. To have a cat at Bay Colony I there is a required deposit of $250. This building has monthly fee of $50 for cats.
