Your next chapter begins in this rare 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment tucked inside a beautifully converted estate. Both bedrooms are equal in size, giving you flexible options whether you're sharing with a roommate or want a dedicated guest room or home office. The eat-in kitchen is designed with plenty of counter space and cabinets, making cooking and storage effortless. The bathroom is especially spacious, featuring a walk-in vanity area and extra storage to keep things organized and clutter-free. Outside, you'll enjoy a large shared yard that feels more like a private park, with the historic Genkinger estate mansion right across the street adding to the charm. It's the perfect blend of peaceful surroundings and convenient access to all that New Castle has to offer. Renter's insurance required.
Thank you for your interest in Premier Property Management! Visit www. Online applications must be submitted through our website. Thank you!
1004 Butler Ave
New Castle, PA 16101
Apartment building
1-4 beds
Available units
This building may have units for rent or for sale. Select a unit to contact.
What's special
Large shared yardExtra storageEat-in kitchenPrivate parkWalk-in vanity area
Facts, features & policies
Unit features
Appliances
- Refrigerator
Neighborhood: 16101
- Historic AreaRich history reflected in architecture, landmarks, and charming old-town character.Community VibeStrong neighborhood connections and community events foster a friendly atmosphere.Outdoor ActivitiesAmple parks and spaces for hiking, biking, and active recreation.Highway AccessQuick highway connections for seamless travel and regional access.
Centered on New Castle, 16101 blends small-city comfort with rich history—the Fireworks Capital legacy, the Scottish Rite Cathedral, and the Warner Cascade Theatre Museum—plus true four seasons (snowy winters, colorful falls, warm summers). Green escapes are close: waterfalls and trails at Cascade Park, biking on the Stavich Trail, and fishing or paddling on Neshannock Creek. Evenings lean low-key with community shows at New Castle Playhouse, tastings at Neshannock Creek Brewing Co., and a classic diner-and-pizza dining scene. Daily life is convenient: groceries at Giant Eagle, Aldi, and Walmart Supercenter, coffee at The Confluence, workouts at Planet Fitness and the YMCA, and shopping clusters along Wilmington Road; I-376, US-422, and PA-18 make it commuter friendly. According to Zillow Market Trends in recent months, the median asking rent has been around $1,000, with most listings roughly $700–$1,300, keeping the area budget-friendly. Neighborhoods tend to be family- and pet-friendly, with front-porch culture, quiet streets, and plenty of space for walks.
Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Nearby schools in New Castle
GreatSchools rating
- 6/10Washington Intrmd SchoolGrades: 3-5Distance: 1.9 mi
- 4/10NEW CASTLE JHSGrades: 6-8Distance: 1.1 mi
- 4/10New Castle Junior-Senior High SchoolGrades: 9-12Distance: 1.1 mi
Frequently asked questions
What is the walk score of 1004 Butler Ave?
1004 Butler Ave has a walk score of 53, it's somewhat walkable.
What schools are assigned to 1004 Butler Ave?
The schools assigned to 1004 Butler Ave include Washington Intrmd School, NEW CASTLE JHS, and New Castle Junior-Senior High School.
What neighborhood is 1004 Butler Ave in?
1004 Butler Ave is in the 16101 neighborhood in New Castle, PA.
