Skip main navigation

    • 16 Penny Ln

    Hampton Bays, NY 11946

    Apartment building
    1-3 beds

    What’s available

    This building may have units for rent. Select a unit to contact.
    $4,000
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 8

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,000
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 7

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,000
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 11

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,000
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 15

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 12

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 5

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 1

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 4

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 3

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 2

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    1 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 6

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,300
    2 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 16

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $4,800
    2 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 10

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $5,700
    2 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 14

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $11,000
    3 bd, 4 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    $39,000
    2 bd, 1 ba
    -- sqft
    For rent - Unit 9

    Listing by: Marquis New York LLC

    What's special

    Private marinaCottage suiteOutdoor patioWaterfront propertyBbq grillsOutdoor pool

    Neighborhood: 11946

    This area blends rental homes, cottages, and apartments near the bay. Renters enjoy a coastal lifestyle with fishing, boating, and seasonal community festivals. The pace is casual yet lively. Median rents sit around $3,600, typically $2,800–$4,400.

    Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.

    Areas of interest

    Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

    Travel times

    Walk, Transit & Bike Scores

    18 / 100
    Car-Dependent
    31 / 100
    Somewhat Bikeable

    Nearby schools in Hampton Bays

    GreatSchools rating

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the walk score of 16 Penny Ln?

    16 Penny Ln has a walk score of 18, it's car-dependent.

    What schools are assigned to 16 Penny Ln?

    The schools assigned to 16 Penny Ln include Hampton Bays Elementary School, Hampton Bays Middle School, and Hampton Bays Secondary School.

    What neighborhood is 16 Penny Ln in?

    16 Penny Ln is in the 11946 neighborhood in Hampton Bays, NY.

    Market Trends

    Rental market summary

    The average rent for all beds and all property types in Hampton Bays, NY is $11,000.

    Average rent

    $11,000

    Month-over-month

    -$4,000

    Year-over-year

    -$8,714

    Available rentals

    170

    Hampton Bays, NY Rental Market Data