Skip main navigation

Shelter Island, NY Housing Market

$1,758,018

5.4% 1-yr

The average Shelter Island, NY home value is $1,758,018, up 5.4% over the past year.

What is the Zillow Home Values Index?

Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), built from the ground up by measuring monthly changes in property level Zestimates, captures both the level and home values across a wide variety of geographies and housing types.

Learn more about the Zillow Home Value Index

Shelter Island Key Takeaways

Typical Home Values: $1,758,018

1-year Value Change: +5.4%

(Data through September 30, 2025)

Shelter Island Housing Market Overview

--1-year Market Forecast
86For sale inventory(September 30, 2025)
11New listings(September 30, 2025)
--Median sale to list ratio
--Median sale price(August 31, 2025)
$2,431,000Median list price(September 30, 2025)
--Percent of sales over list price
--Percent of sales under list price
--Median days to pending
(Metric availability is based on market coverage and data)
How does this data help me?
Zillow's metrics provide valuable market data by tracking market changes in different locations and housing types.

Nearby Neighborhoods

Move forward with a local partner

Zillow is more than a place to browse homes. It’s a place to connect with a local agent, explore financing solutions, schedule home tours, understand your buying and selling power, and more.

Talk to a local agent
Get pre-qualified for a loan
At Zillow Home Loans, we can pre-qualify you in as little as 5 minutes with no impact on your credit score.
Start Now
An equal housing lender. NMLS #10287.

Shelter Island Rental Market Trends

--Average rent in Shelter Island
$1,979National average rent(September 30, 2025)
--Month-over-month change
--Year-over-year change
How does this data help me?
The Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) measures changes in asking rents over time, controlling for changes in the quality of the available rental inventory.

More on Zillow Research