Welcome to Allen Bay, where modern apartment living meets the comfort of an established Middleton neighborhood.
Tucked along a quiet residential cul-de-sac, Allen Bay offers spacious, thoughtfully designed apartment homes with the everyday conveniences that make life easier. Enjoy inviting indoor and outdoor amenity spaces, complimentary underground parking, and spacious apartments to truly make yourself at home.
With Marshall Park and Lake Mendota just steps away, outdoor recreation is always close at hand. And with convenient access to Middleton, Madison, Verona, and the surrounding region, you're connected to the places that matter while enjoying a quieter setting to come home to.
More space. Less crowds. A comfortable place to call home.
Allen Bay
2164 Middleton Beach Rd, Madison, WI 53562
Apartment building
1-2 beds
Pet-friendly
Attached garage
Air conditioning (central)
In-unit laundry (W/D)
Available units
 Unit 2152-203 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,800 | |
Unit 2164-203 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,800 | |
 Unit 2152-211 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
Unit 2152-303 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
Unit 2152-311 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
Unit 2164-211 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
Unit 2164-303 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
Unit 2164-311 1 bd, 1 ba | 762 | Now | $1,950 | |
 Unit 2164-305 1 bd, 1 ba | 778 | Now | $2,000 | |
 Unit 2164-309 1 bd, 1 ba | 778 | Now | $2,000 | |
Unit 2152-305 1 bd, 1 ba | 778 | Now | $2,025 | |
Unit 2152-309 1 bd, 1 ba | 778 | Now | $2,025 | |
 Unit 2152-212 1 bd, 1 ba | 927 | Now | $2,295 | |
 Unit 2164-200 1 bd, 1 ba | 927 | Now | $2,295 | |
Unit 2164-212 1 bd, 1 ba | 927 | Now | $2,295 | |
What's special
Clubhouse
Get the party started
This building features a clubhouse. Less than 16% of buildings in Middleton have this amenity.
Spacious apartmentsQuiet residential cul-de-sac
Property map
Tap on any highlighted unit to view details on availability and pricing
Use ctrl + scroll to zoom the map
Facts, features & policies
Building Amenities
Accessibility
- Disabled Access
Community Rooms
- Club House
- Fitness Center
- Library
- Lounge
- Party Room
- Pet Washing Station
Fitness & sports
- Other Sports Court
Other
- Laundry: In Unit
Outdoor common areas
- Barbecue
- Deck
- Garden
- Lawn
- Patio
- Rooftop Deck
- Water Feature
Security
- Controlled Access
Services & facilities
- 24 Hour Maintenance
- Bicycle Storage
- Elevator
- On-Site Management
- Online Maintenance Portal
- Online Rent Payment
- Package Service
View description
- Water
- Wooded
Unit Features
Appliances
- Dishwasher
- Dryer
- Freezer
- Garbage Disposal
- Microwave Oven
- Oven
- Range
- Refrigerator
- Washer
Cooling
- Ceiling Fan
- Central Air Conditioning
Flooring
- Carpet
- Laminate
Heating
- Electric
Internet/Satellite
- Building-Wide Wireless
- High-Speed Internet Ready
Other
- Patio Balcony
Policies
Parking
- Attached Garage
- Covered Parking
Lease terms
- More than 1 year
- One year
Special Features
- Beach Access Next Door
- Boat Landing Next Door
- Communal Fire Pits
- Madison Boats Discounted Memberships
- Parcel Room With Refridgeration Storage
Neighborhood: 53705
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Getting around
Walk Score®
 / 100
Car-DependentTransit Score®
 / 100
Some TransitBike Score®
 / 100
Very BikeableNearby schools in Madison
Sauk Trail Elementary School
Grades PK-4 • 0.6 miles5/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
6/10Student Progress Rating
4/10Kromrey Middle School
Grades 5-8 • 1.3 miles9/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
9/10Student Progress Rating
8/10Middleton High School
Grades 9-12 • 1.3 miles9/10
GreatSchools® Rating
College Readiness Rating
10/10Student Progress Rating
9/10Living in Madison
Madison’s Regent, Hill Farms, University Neighborhood, Parkwood West Condominium, Parkwood Village and Sunset Village sit west of downtown, with Shorewood Hills nearby and Lake Mendota shaping the northern edge. The area has four-season weather, wooded residential streets and easy access to the University of Wisconsin–Madison campus, the Wisconsin State Capitol and the lakeshore. Outdoor options include Shorewood Hills’ parks and paths, nearby University Bay and trails around the Lakeshore Nature Preserve; playgrounds and the Sequoya Branch Library add everyday destinations. Local dining and coffee spots mix with shopping along University Avenue and in Hilldale, while campus venues bring museums, performances and evening events. Biking and walking are practical for nearby destinations, and Madison Metro buses connect the area with campus and downtown. For ZIP code 53705, the median rent is $1,866 per month, with a typical range of $200 to $6,084.
Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.
Cost calculator
Nearby apartments for rent
Listing order may reflect relevance, quality, and paid promotion.
Similar apartments for rent
Frequently asked questions
Where is Allen Bay located, and what is the neighborhood like?
Allen Bay is located at 2164 Middleton Beach Rd, Madison, WI. The surrounding area includes multiple restaurants and cafes within 2 miles, such as Sunshine Sips, Imperial Garden, and Scooter's Coffee.
What is the average rent in Madison, WI?
Based on the latest Zillow data, the median rent across all unit types in ZIP code 53562 in Madison is currently $1,866 per month. Prices vary by neighborhood, floor plan, and building amenities.
What schools are assigned to Allen Bay?
The schools assigned to Allen Bay include Sauk Trail Elementary School, Kromrey Middle School, and Middleton High School.
What are the grocery stores and everyday shopping options near Allen Bay?
Allen Bay is located near 6 grocery stores, including Community Wellness Shop (0.4 miles) and Abarrotes Yuremi (0.6 miles). Additional shopping options, including Wolff Kubly Middleton Ace, are approximately 0.4 miles away.
What is the minimum and maximum rent for Allen Bay?
The total price for an apartment unit in Allen Bay ranges from $1,800 to $2,800. The total price will vary by floor plan, unit size, and unit amenities.
