125 Rio Del Mar St

Butler Beach is a coastal neighborhood south of St. Augustine, set along Anastasia Island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Intracoastal Waterway. Its Atlantic shoreline, warm humid climate and beach access shape everyday outdoor life, with the nearby Matanzas Inlet offering another striking coastal landscape. Anastasia State Park, just north on the island, has trails, natural beach and opportunities for paddling and wildlife viewing; local beach access points make walks by the water easy. Dining options include casual seafood spots and cafés, while shopping is mostly practical and concentrated along nearby A1A. Historic sites and the arts, dining and nightlife of downtown St. Augustine are a drive away. A car is useful for errands and getting around, though the coastal road links the neighborhood to nearby beaches and the city. Butler Beach neighborhood rental data show a median rent of $3,799 per month and a typical range of $2,734 to $16,262.