With mortgage payments up nearly 13% from a year ago, affordability is still a hurdle. Knowing recent sale prices can help buyers and sellers find common ground.

Written by Grant Brissey on November 19, 2026
Edited by Jessica Rapp
Sellers set the asking price. But the sale price is an agreement between a buyer and a seller. If you’re pricing a home or planning an offer, getting familiar with recent, local sale prices can deliver a clearer picture of the market.
In the first week of October, more than 55% of homes sold for less than their asking price. That’s closer to pre-pandemic numbers. In 2018 and 2019, the share hovered around 61% in the first week of October. By 2021 it had dipped below 35%. Looking back, 2021 was the outlier, when nearly two-thirds of homes sold at or above asking.
“Selling for less than the asking price was business as usual before the pandemic, and the market is drifting back in that direction,” says Zillow Chief Economist Mischa Fisher. “With rates above 7% heading into the holidays, sellers who price to recent nearby sales and buyers who know their budget have the best shot at meeting in the middle.”
And meeting in the middle is more necessary in tighter housing markets. October sales of existing homes were down close to 9% from the prior year, and newly pending sales fell 16.8%, the largest drop since August 2023.
The numbers still tell a familiar story: Affordability remains a major hurdle for homebuyers. The typical mortgage payment is up nearly 13% year over year, driven almost entirely by rates. And when too few people can afford to buy, it’s a hurdle for sellers too.
Zillow economists don’t expect rates to ease much in the near future, with projections above 7% for 2026 and above 6.5% in 2027. And while rates are a major part of any homebuying equation, prices are another major factor that often gets less attention.
If there’s an opportunity for both buyers and sellers in this market, it’s in price. Sellers can move their home quicker by pricing appropriately, and buyers can still find good prices if they’re willing to negotiate and test asking prices.
Nationally, 55.4% of homes sold below list price in early October. Here’s how the 50 largest U.S. metro areas compare.
| Metro | Share sold below list |
| Miami, FL | 77.2% |
| Austin, TX | 72.2% |
| New Orleans, LA | 70.5% |
| Jacksonville, FL | 69.7% |
| Houston, TX | 68.1% |
| Orlando, FL | 67.5% |
| Tampa, FL | 67.2% |
| Raleigh, NC | 66.4% |
| Dallas, TX | 65.9% |
| Nashville, TN | 65.2% |
| Metro | Share sold below list |
| Hartford, CT | 22.2% |
| Buffalo, NY | 22.6% |
| San Francisco, CA | 32.4% |
| Virginia Beach, VA | 32.7% |
| Baltimore, MD | 38.7% |
| Providence, RI | 40.7% |
| San Jose, CA | 40.9% |
| New York, NY | 41.1% |
| Richmond, VA | 41.2% |
| Milwaukee, WI | 42.2% |
Source: Zillow Research, week ending Oct. 3, 2026. Figures are smoothed and cover the 50 largest U.S. metro areas.
Selling below asking is the norm in Miami, where about 3 in 4 homes sold for less than their list price in the first week of October, compared with just over half of homes nationally. Still, it was the only one of the 50 largest metros where home values rose from September to October.
Curious about the area? See what it’s like to live in Miami and explore its best neighborhoods.
When more than half of homes sell for less than their asking price, the list price often leaves room to negotiate. That can be especially true late in the year, when many sellers hope to close before the holidays. With borrowing costs higher than a year ago, a lower purchase price can help a home fit your monthly budget.
Buyer tip: Ask about more than the price. Sellers may be open to covering closing costs or paying to lower your mortgage rate, which can ease your monthly payment.
Buyer tip: Take a second look at homes that have been on the market for a while. Nationally, homes are taking about a month to go under contract, and sellers who have waited longer may be more open to an offer. On Zillow, use the Days on Zillow filter under More to find homes that have been listed longer. You can also check a listing’s price history for past price cuts.
Buyer tip: Know your budget before you make an offer. BuyAbility shows which homes fit your budget at today’s rates.
With mortgage payments up from a year ago, many buyers are shopping on tighter budgets. For sellers, a sale below asking is common, and it can still be a successful outcome. A success could mean closing on your timeline at a price that’s in line with recent nearby sales.
Seller tip: Be ready to talk through options with your agent, from pricing adjustments to a mortgage rate buydown. Flexibility can help keep your home within reach when rates are working against buyers.
Seller tip: Price your home based on recent nearby sale prices. With more than half of homes selling below asking, those numbers show what buyers are actually paying.
Seller tip: Have a plan for your first month on the market. Ask your agent how long homes are taking to go under contract in your area, and decide with them when you’d revisit price or terms.