Skip main navigation

Jay Starr

(He/Him/His)
RE/MAX 1st Advantage
5.015 reviews
Contact Jay

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $385,000
    4 bd3 ba2,516 sqft Orrtanna, PA
    4 bd3 ba2,516 sqft
    Orrtanna, PA
    Sold 8 days ago
    Seller
    3065 Buchanan Valley Rd, Orrtanna, PA, 17353
  • $384,900
    3 bd3 ba3,384 sqft Greencastle, PA
    3 bd3 ba3,384 sqft
    Greencastle, PA
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    408 Carolle St, Greencastle, PA, 17225
  • $295,000
    3 bd3 ba1,732 sqft Waynesboro, PA
    3 bd3 ba1,732 sqft
    Waynesboro, PA
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    11196 Gopher Dr N, Waynesboro, PA, 17268
  • $269,500
    -- bd-- ba-- -- Clear Spring, MD
    -- bd-- ba-- --
    Clear Spring, MD
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    0 Hanging Rock Rd, Clear Spring, MD, 21722
  • $302,000
    3 bd2 ba2,140 sqft Fayetteville, PA
    3 bd2 ba2,140 sqft
    Fayetteville, PA
    Sold 2 months ago
    Seller
    21 Hillcrest Rd, Fayetteville, PA, 17222
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
21
Sales last 12 months
240
Total sales
$28K-$1.1M
Price range
$315K
Average price

Get to know Jay Starr

Real Estate Professional

Jay Starr is a full-time REALTOR® and Team Leader of The Jay Starr Team at RE/MAX 1st Advantage. With 22+ years of experience and more than 300 homes sold, Jay serves buyers and sellers throughout South-Central PA and Central MD. He specializes in luxury homes, residential estates, farms, large land tracts, hunting properties, and investment properties. Jay is a Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist, a RE/MAX 100% Club award winner, and has ...

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentRelocationForeclosureVacation / Short-term RentalsFirst Time HomebuyersInvestment PropertiesLuxury HomesSenior CommunitiesLot/Land
22 Years of experience
Visit agent website
FacebookInstagramLinkedIn

Jay Starr's sales and listings (246)

This map and property list shows the most recent 100 sales and 100 listings

Sold
For sale
Skip sales and listings map
Go back to the sales and listings map

Sold (240)

Skip to the end of the carousel
Skip to the beginning of the carousel

For sale (6)

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • RE/MAX 1st Advantage
Skip to the beginning of the carousel

Jay Starr's reviews (15)

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • 5.0
    • 9/21/2021
    • • JeremyHelman

    Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Chambersburg, PA.

    Jay has all the qualities required to be an elite agent. What he has on top of that is patience. We looked at many houses, and had 4 offers go a different way. Never di...
    Jay has all the qualities required to be an elite agent. What he has on top of that is patience. We looked at many houses, and ha...
    5.0
    • 7/7/2021
    • • levi l crouse

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Chambersburg, PA.

    Jay first helped us find and purchase our first home almost 10 years ago and was great to work with then. Fast forward to the summer of 2020 and he gave advice on what we...
    Jay first helped us find and purchase our first home almost 10 years ago and was great to work with then. Fast forward to the summ...
  • 5.0
    • 5/30/2020
    • • Elena Salazar

    Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Greencastle, PA.

    Jay is a pleasure to work with. He brings a perfect balance of professionalism, experience and knowledge of the real estate business without compromising on integrity. We...
    Jay is a pleasure to work with. He brings a perfect balance of professionalism, experience and knowledge of the real estate busine...
    5.0
    • 5/30/2020
    • • Lenore Stains

    Sold a Mobile / Manufactured home in 2020 in Saint thomas, PA.

    As a first time seller I did not know how to go through this process. Jay did not miss a beat in making this happen for me. He was the spot for everything that need att...
    As a first time seller I did not know how to go through this process. Jay did not miss a beat in making this happen for me. He wa...
  • 5.0
    • 5/6/2020
    • • bigbob1015

    Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Greencastle, PA.

    Jay was a pleasure to work with. After another realtor failed to schedule appointments to even tour my home, I hired Jay and we had multiple offers on the table soon afte...
    Jay was a pleasure to work with. After another realtor failed to schedule appointments to even tour my home, I hired Jay and we ha...
    5.0
    • 12/16/2019
    • • Beth shauf

    Bought a home in 2019 in PA 17256.

    Jay was very helpful and walked us through every part of the transaction. He kept us informed every step of the way and helped deal with issues that arose and assisted wi...
    Jay was very helpful and walked us through every part of the transaction. He kept us informed every step of the way and helped dea...
  • 5.0
    • 9/3/2016
    • • kisses2eks

    Bought a Single Family home in 2016 in Saint thomas, PA.

    Jay was very helpful in helping us find a new house. He recommended a financial institution that helped us with our needs. He was always in contact with us if the finan...
    Jay was very helpful in helping us find a new house. He recommended a financial institution that helped us with our needs. He wa...
    5.0
    • 8/22/2016
    • • amethystangel777

    Bought a Single Family home in 2016 in Fayetteville, PA.

    My husband and I have been looking for homes for over 2 years. I finally decided to find someone new to help us. We started looking at houses with Jay at the end of May/ ...
    My husband and I have been looking for homes for over 2 years. I finally decided to find someone new to help us. We started lookin...
  • 5.0
    • 7/16/2016
    • • dmberard7

    Sold a Single Family home in 2016 in Fayetteville, PA.

    We had a mountain cabin for sale for three years with another real estate agent and had not one offer. We signed with Jay in April and had settlement on July 1. Jay was v...
    We had a mountain cabin for sale for three years with another real estate agent and had not one offer. We signed with Jay in April...
    5.0
    • 7/15/2016
    • • a1greencastleselfstorage

    Bought a home in 2015 in PA 17202.

    I would most definitely recommend Jay. We were so indecisive on houses and he really helped us find the right home and worked with out crazy schedules. So friendly and he...
    I would most definitely recommend Jay. We were so indecisive on houses and he really helped us find the right home and worked with...
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
Add a review

Service areas (18)

Jay Starr

(He/Him/His)
RE/MAX 1st Advantage
5.015 reviews
21sales last 12 months
240total sales
$28K-$1.1Mprice range
$315Kaverage price
22years of experience
(717) 658-0177
(717) 591-5555
Jay@JayStarr.Com
6375 Mercury DR
Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050