Mystic Isle Realty is the oldest and most established real estate company on Fishers Island. Fishers Island is located in Long Island Sound between southeast Ct. and Montauk, Long Island. The island runs west to east and is about seven miles long and accessible by ferry from New London, Ct. Mystic Isle Realty handles both sales and rentals on Fishers Island and has a vast knoweledge of the ins and out of the island. Please view our website at www... Show more