Skip main navigation

Toni Bontrager

Hallmark Excellence Realty

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $580,000
    5 bd3 ba3,807 sqft Goshen, IN
    5 bd3 ba3,807 sqft
    Goshen, IN
    Sold 9 days ago
    Seller
    16123 County Road 18, Goshen, IN, 46528
  • $60,000
    -- bd-- ba-- -- Shipshewana, IN
    -- bd-- ba-- --
    Shipshewana, IN
    Sold 11 days ago
    BuyerSeller
    3175 N 982 W, Shipshewana, IN, 46565
  • $320,000
    3 bd2 ba2,264 sqft Elkhart, IN
    3 bd2 ba2,264 sqft
    Elkhart, IN
    Sold 28 days ago
    Buyer
    29876 County Road 18, Elkhart, IN, 46517
  • $499,000
    3 bd2 ba3,028 sqft Middlebury, IN
    3 bd2 ba3,028 sqft
    Middlebury, IN
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    401 W Warren St, Middlebury, IN, 46540
  • $490,000
    5 bd3 ba2,960 sqft Middlebury, IN
    5 bd3 ba2,960 sqft
    Middlebury, IN
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    225 Greenfield Dr, Middlebury, IN, 46540
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
39
Sales last 12 months
782
Total sales
$60K-$1.4M
Price range
$315K
Average price

Get to know Toni Bontrager

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentRelocation

Toni Bontrager's listings & sales (791)

For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.

For Sale (9)

Sold (782)

Address
Sold date
Closing price
Represented
Flag Sale
7/30/2025$580,000Seller
7/28/2025$60,000Buyer and Seller
7/11/2025$320,000Buyer
6/30/2025$499,000Seller
6/30/2025$490,000Seller

Toni Bontrager's reviews (4)

Write a review
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    12/3/2016 - user6422485
    Bought a Single Family home in 2016 in Middlebury, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Toni worked with us for a couple of years before we found the perfect house. She was very patient and showed us easily a couple dozen houses. We were very happy as ultimately she helped us negotiate deals on two very different properties. I'm sure...
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    12/3/2016 - Susan Mosey
    Bought a Single Family home in 2016 in Middlebury, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    When we started looking for a home, we had an unrealistically low budget, but Toni had the patience of a saint! Eventually with her help, we found and bought our dream house. Throughout the process, her responsiveness to texts/emails was excellent....
  • Likely to recommend4.04.0

    10/21/2014 - user31073763
    Sold a Single Family home in 2014 in Middlebury, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Recently sold our home with Toni. Best not to have her represent both seller and buyer. In our case she was representing the buyers even thou we had the contract with her. Felt her concern was business she could obtain thru buyers network. She is a ...
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    10/6/2011 - gng1939
    Sold a Single Family home in 2005 in Bent oak, Elkhart, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Alway willing and ready to service beyond her duties as an realtor. Very, very nice to work with. I decided not to sell at this time; that didn't make a difference with her readiness to help in anyway.

Service areas (1)

Toni Bontrager

Hallmark Excellence Realty
39sales last 12 months
782total sales
$60K-$1.4Mprice range
$315Kaverage price