$1,110,000
4 bd4 ba3,391 sqft Sister Bay, WI
4 bd4 ba3,391 sqft
Sister Bay, WI
Sold 27 days ago
Seller
Get to know MaryKay Shumway
Broker/ABR/CRS
I can trace my Door County heritage back to settlers from Washington Island and Liberty Grove in the 1800s. I have two daughters who have attended our local school district at Gibraltar Area Schools in Fish Creek, Wisconsin. We chose to settle on the Door Peninsula and raise our family here because there is truly no other place like Door County, Wisconsin.
My background is as diverse as the exceptional properties I represent. Active in the nor...
Specialties
22 Years of experienceBuyer's AgentListing AgentNotaryNew Construction
MaryKay Shumway's listings & sales (120)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (10)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 Tbd N Cave Point Dr Jacksonport, WI 54235
| $800,000 | |
 5796 N Cave Point Dr Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $2,100,000 |
 10701 Timber Ridge Cir #8B-30 Sister Bay, WI 54234
| 2 Bed, 2 Bath | $329,900 |
 633 Isle View Rd Ellison Bay, WI 54210
| 3 Bed, 3 Bath | $1,200,000 |
 Fawn Ln Ellison Bay, WI 54210
| $99,900 |
Sold (110)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/19/2025 | $1,110,000 | Seller | ||
| 12/8/2025 | $775,000 | Buyer | ||
| 11/24/2025 | $1,355,000 | Seller | ||
| 11/21/2025 | $332,000 | Seller | ||
| 11/21/2025 | $356,000 | Buyer |
MaryKay Shumway's reviews (33)
- 5.0
- 11/13/2025
- • mollyhsalisbury
Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Ellison bay, WI.
MaryKay’s professionalism, market knowledge, and prompt response to any and all questions made the sale of our home a seamless experience. Her vast knowledge of resourc...MaryKay’s professionalism, market knowledge, and prompt response to any and all questions made the sale of our home a seamless e...5.0- 7/2/2024
- • zuser20140313134713321
Sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Sturgeon bay, WI.
MaryKay was an extraordinarily asset to this sales transaction. 22 days after putting my father's home on the market, we have closed!!! She was sensitive to the emotion...MaryKay was an extraordinarily asset to this sales transaction. 22 days after putting my father's home on the market, we have clo... - 5.0
- 9/16/2021
- • gmethner
Sold a home in 2021 in OH 43211.
From our first conversation to closing, MaryKay ensured that our experience was productive and positive. My wife and I couldn't have been more pleased with her timely fo...From our first conversation to closing, MaryKay ensured that our experience was productive and positive. My wife and I couldn't h...5.0- 9/9/2021
- • Scraft747
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Sister bay, WI.
MaryKay recently helped us with the purchase of a home in Sister Bay, WI. We couldn't have been happier or more impressed with how the process went from the first phone ...MaryKay recently helped us with the purchase of a home in Sister Bay, WI. We couldn't have been happier or more impressed with ho... - 5.0
- 9/7/2021
- • carriea weiss
Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Sister bay, WI.
We had an excellent experience selling our Door County home with MaryKay! MaryKay was always available to answer our questions, and she was extremely helpful getting our ...We had an excellent experience selling our Door County home with MaryKay! MaryKay was always available to answer our questions, an...5.0- 6/19/2020
- • Tom Buerger
Bought a home in 2020 in WI 54211.
If you're looking in Door County you MUST use MaryKay. We are moving from Chicago and (this is our 6th move) have never had anyone so knowledgable, responsive, and thor...If you're looking in Door County you MUST use MaryKay. We are moving from Chicago and (this is our 6th move) have never had anyo... - 5.0
- 8/25/2019
- • mark koenig4
Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Ellison bay, WI.
We chose to list our home near Europe Lake with MaryKay because of her professionalism and knowledge of Door County valuations. Our time from listing to close was approx...We chose to list our home near Europe Lake with MaryKay because of her professionalism and knowledge of Door County valuations. O...5.0- 7/7/2019
- • Nancy Brock
Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Ellison bay, WI.
Very knowledgeable and guided us through the sale of our home in a professional manner! MaryKay is the best and I highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy or ...Very knowledgeable and guided us through the sale of our home in a professional manner! MaryKay is the best and I highly recommend... - 5.0
- 4/6/2019
- • heygardengirl
Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Sister bay, WI.
MaryKay was wonderful to work with. She is professional, experienced, knowledgeable, and efficient. She sold my home to a very difficult buyer but maintained her sense ...MaryKay was wonderful to work with. She is professional, experienced, knowledgeable, and efficient. She sold my home to a very d...5.0- 12/3/2018
- • lois huggins
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Ellison bay, WI.
We feel very fortunate to have selected MaryKay to represent us in selling our Door County home. She is very creative in her marketing and use of social media, possesses ...We feel very fortunate to have selected MaryKay to represent us in selling our Door County home. She is very creative in her marke...
