Skip main navigation

Nicole Mathew

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $244,900
    2 bd2 ba1,974 sqft Medaryville, IN
    2 bd2 ba1,974 sqft
    Medaryville, IN
    Sold 10 days ago
    Buyer
    2916 N Us Highway 421, Medaryville, IN, 47957
  • $270,000
    3 bd2 ba1,782 sqft Winamac, IN
    3 bd2 ba1,782 sqft
    Winamac, IN
    Sold 1 month ago
    Seller
    3533 N 400 W, Winamac, IN, 46996
  • $136,000
    3 bd1 ba1,143 sqft Kentland, IN
    3 bd1 ba1,143 sqft
    Kentland, IN
    Sold 3 months ago
    Buyer
    213 W Railroad St, Kentland, IN, 47951
  • $241,900
    4 bd2 ba1,804 sqft Rensselaer, IN
    4 bd2 ba1,804 sqft
    Rensselaer, IN
    Sold 4 months ago
    Buyer
    1017 N Weston St, Rensselaer, IN, 47978
  • $70,000
    5 bd2 ba1,538 sqft Morocco, IN
    5 bd2 ba1,538 sqft
    Morocco, IN
    Sold 4 months ago
    Buyer
    210 E Grove St, Morocco, IN, 47963
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
16
Sales last 12 months
249
Total sales
$26K-$380K
Price range
$185K
Average price

Get to know Nicole Mathew

Broker Associate

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentForeclosureProperty ManagementFirst Time Homebuyers

Nicole Mathew's listings & sales (253)

For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.

For Sale (4)

Sold (249)

Address
Sold date
Closing price
Represented
Flag Sale
8/14/2025$244,900Buyer
7/11/2025$270,000Seller
5/20/2025$136,000Buyer
5/6/2025$241,900Buyer
5/1/2025$70,000Buyer

Nicole Mathew's reviews (22)

Write a review
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    3/16/2019 - lrberenda
    Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Rensselaer, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Nicole and her broker did a tremendous job with negotiations and went above and beyond finding solutions to close the sale. Going with another broker would have resulted in leaving money on the table. She is truly professional and answered all of o...
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    11/30/2017 - tmassoels1990
    Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Rensselaer, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Selling my house on my own wasn't working so I called Nicole Mathew. She listed the house the very next day and within the 1st week we had multiple families come through to look at the house. Two offers were made in less than 30 days and closing to...
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    11/30/2017 - AbbyThiel
    Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Rensselaer, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    I used to be the person that thought it didn't matter who you listed with, selling a house was just selling a house. For nearly 3 years I tried selling my house with a different real estate, with no luck. I had it listed with Nicole for almost 4 mont...
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    7/31/2017 - adopt32001
    Bought a Mobile / Manufactured home in 2017 in Knox, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Nicole was professional and friendly. She responded quickly to all my questions and definitely went above and beyond to help the home buying process go as smoothly as possible. I was very pleased.
  • Highly likely to recommend5.05.0

    1/25/2017 - philip a watkins
    Bought a Single Family home in 2017 in Rensselaer, IN.

    Local knowledge
    Process expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    Nicole exercised her advanced knowledge of the area to find my family the best home money could buy. As a first time home buyer she was always readily available to answer any questions we had regarding the complex and confusing paperwork, breaking it...

Service areas (0)

    Nicole Mathew

    16sales last 12 months
    249total sales
    $26K-$380Kprice range
    $185Kaverage price