$225,000
3 bd3 ba1,820 sqft Youngstown, OH
3 bd3 ba1,820 sqft
Youngstown, OH
Sold 7 days ago
Seller
Get to know Tibitha Matheney
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Let me help you "Move On" with your life
"Hello!
I was born and raised in the Austintown, Ohio area, and I currently reside there. Licensed since 2003, I work full-time around my clients' schedules! Let me know if I can help you in any way when selling or buying!
I service Mahoning, Columbiana and Trumbull Counties! I am also able to assist people in finding a great agent when they move out of town to another place, so don't be afraid to ask!
I m...
23 Years of experience
Tibitha Matheney's listings & sales (1501)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (13)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 3555 W South Range Rd Columbiana, OH 44408
| 4 Bed, 3 Bath | $270,000 |
 5200 West Blvd APT 505 Youngstown, OH 44512
| 1 Bed, 1 Bath | $109,000 |
 325 S Inglewood Ave Youngstown, OH 44515
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $245,000 |
 583 Wyndclift Cir Youngstown, OH 44515
| 3 Bed, 3 Bath | $319,900 |
 104 S Glenellen Ave Youngstown, OH 44509
| 2 Bed, 2 Bath | $69,900 |
For Rent (3)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 8190 Southern Blvd APT 1 Youngstown, OH 44512
| 2 Bed, 1 Bath | $1,200/mo |
 4866 Norquest Blvd Youngstown, OH 44515
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $1,800/mo |
 230 Dehoff Dr Youngstown, OH 44515
| 3 Bed, 1 Bath | $1,425/mo |
Sold (1485)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2/20/2026 | $225,000 | Seller | ||
| 1/30/2026 | $185,500 | Seller | ||
| 1/29/2026 | $279,900 | Seller | ||
| 1/15/2026 | $147,500 | Seller | ||
| 1/12/2026 | $122,000 | Seller |
Tibitha Matheney's reviews (136)
- 5.0
- 2/25/2026
- • jpo825
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha and her assistant did an outstanding job helping us sell our house. We purchased the house through Tibitha back in 2012 and knew it was in our best interest to st...Tibitha and her assistant did an outstanding job helping us sell our house. We purchased the house through Tibitha back in 2012 an...5.0- 2/24/2026
- • cherry2205
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha Matheney is an excellent realtor! She goes above and beyond to help you every step of the way! She is very knowledgeable and works hard to help you through the wh...Tibitha Matheney is an excellent realtor! She goes above and beyond to help you every step of the way! She is very knowledgeable a... - 5.0
- 2/2/2026
- • Ryan Halicki
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Howland center, Warren, OH.
Tibitha was referred to us from a friend and did not disappoint! She was clear and concise with us and made selling our father’s home a breeze. Would recommend to anyone ...Tibitha was referred to us from a friend and did not disappoint! She was clear and concise with us and made selling our father’s h...5.0- 1/16/2026
- • jeanettefolliett
Sold a home in 2026.
Tibitha Matheney did her research and suggested a price that would sell quickly. The home sold within three days with a full price offer. She responded quickly to all my ...Tibitha Matheney did her research and suggested a price that would sell quickly. The home sold within three days with a full price... - 5.0
- 12/28/2025
- • mamalizia
Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Youngstown, OH.
It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of your house and tells you what to expect....It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of ...5.0- 12/9/2025
- • Brian Gaucher
Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Poland, OH.
Tibitha has been an exceptional realtor to work with. Their communication is always clear, timely, and professional, making every step of the process feel smooth and mana...Tibitha has been an exceptional realtor to work with. Their communication is always clear, timely, and professional, making every ... - 5.0
- 10/30/2025
- • mmtoth0
Bought a home in 2025.
Tibitha did a amazing job helping us get our house. She made sure we could view the house multiple times and got all of the information we needed/requested.Tibitha did a amazing job helping us get our house. She made sure we could view the house multiple times and got all of the inform...5.0- 10/6/2025
- • tomiller1973
Sold a home in 2025.
Tabitha was amazing! She responded to all of my questions without delay. She kept me informed about what was going on with the sale of the house. She is also very prof...Tabitha was amazing! She responded to all of my questions without delay. She kept me informed about what was going on with the s... - 5.0
- 9/10/2025
- • Beverly Laraway
Bought a Condo home in 2025 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha is very knowledgeable, professional, and very easy to work with. She listens to her clients to determine their likes and dislikes and then narrows the search to f...Tibitha is very knowledgeable, professional, and very easy to work with. She listens to her clients to determine their likes and d...5.0- 9/3/2025
- • SLaraway
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Canfield, OH.
Tibitha is an amazing realtor. I have bought and sold four different homes, over the past twenty years, using Tibitha. She is extremely knowledgeable and responsive to an...Tibitha is an amazing realtor. I have bought and sold four different homes, over the past twenty years, using Tibitha. She is extr...
