$217,500
3 bd2 ba1,928 sqft Youngstown, OH
3 bd2 ba1,928 sqft
Youngstown, OH
Sold 6 days ago
Seller
Get to know Tibitha Matheney
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Licensed since 2003, I work full-time and proudly serve Mahoning, Trumbull and Columbiana Counties!
I work with both sellers and buyers! Selling? I communicate well, assess your home in person, gather detailed information, consult and advise, then market strongly and negotiate on your behalf. Buying,? First step, a buyer consultation to discuss the process, your goals and the steps from start to finish! If we fit, we can assemble our buying team,...
Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentFirst Time HomebuyersInvestment PropertiesMilitary/VeteransLuxury HomesSenior CommunitiesLot/Land
SpeaksEnglish, Spanish
23 Years of experienceTibitha Matheney's sales and listings (1,526)
This map and property list shows the most recent 100 sales and 100 listings
Sold
For sale
For rent
Sold (1,519)
- $217,500
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- 1,928 sqft
222 Brookfield Ave, Youngstown, OH 44512Sold 6 days agoSeller
- $133,500
- 4 bd
- 1 ba
- 1,365 sqft
177 Willard Ave SE, Warren, OH 44483Sold 12 days agoBuyer
- $80,000
- 4 bd
- 1 ba
- -- sqft
180 Clarencedale Ave, Youngstown, OH 44512Sold 20 days agoBuyer
- $132,000
- 2 bd
- 1 ba
- 1,120 sqft
43 Washington St, East Palestine, OH 44413Sold 23 days agoSeller
- $269,900
- 4 bd
- 3 ba
- 2,272 sqft
1041 Prentice Rd, Warren, OH 44481Sold 24 days agoSeller
For sale (6)
- $225,000
- 2 bd
- 3 ba
- 1,394 sqft
325 S Linden Ct, Warren, OH 44484House for SaleOpen: Sun 1-2:30pm (8/30)
CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty - $120,000
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- 1,980 sqft
1504 Manhattan Ave, Youngstown, OH 44509House for SalePrice cut: $10,000 (8/17)
- $150,000
- 3 bd
- 1 ba
- 1,096 sqft
1020 Water St, Newton Falls, OH 44444House for SaleAppliances stay
- $35,000
- -- bd
- -- ba
- -- sqft
909 Lisbon Rd, Leetonia, OH 44431House for Sale131 days on Zillow
- $64,900
- -- bd
- -- ba
- -- sqft
902 S Meridian Rd, Youngstown, OH 44509House for Sale167 days on Zillow
For rent (1)
- $900/mo
- 2 bd
- 1 ba
- 510 sqft
8190 Southern Blvd APT 4, Youngstown, OH 44512For rent26 days ago
Tibitha Matheney's reviews (147)
- 5.0
- 8/12/2026
- • gabriel271931
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Pleasant grove, Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha was very kind and thoughtful all throughout the whole process. She was always responsive to my questions and would always give me feedback. She definitely cares a...Tibitha was very kind and thoughtful all throughout the whole process. She was always responsive to my questions and would always ...5.0- 7/31/2026
- • clmedina925
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
As first-time homebuyers, we had absolutely no clue what we were doing, but Tibi made the entire process feel so much less overwhelming. From the beginning, she was patie...As first-time homebuyers, we had absolutely no clue what we were doing, but Tibi made the entire process feel so much less overwhe... - 5.0
- 7/18/2026
- • malbertini325
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
What i expected was a huge complicated experience. What i got was peace of mind andconfidence in Tibitha’s knowledge. I have not bought or sold a house in over 30 yrs s...What i expected was a huge complicated experience. What i got was peace of mind andconfidence in Tibitha’s knowledge. I have not...5.0- 6/25/2026
- • lkiddon4
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
This was our first experience selling a house. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Tibitha Matheney! Tibi was with us every step of the way. From the moment...This was our first experience selling a house. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Tibitha Matheney! Tibi was with u... - 5.0
- 6/12/2026
- • user4546836
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Sandgate, VT.
Tibitha made the process very easy! She was very responsive and walked us through the process every step of the way. I would use her again if I was selling/buying!Tibitha made the process very easy! She was very responsive and walked us through the process every step of the way. I would use h...5.0- 6/9/2026
- • zuser20220329193123327
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha was great to work with! She devoted a lot of time with us and her experience was very helpful during our home buying process. As out of state buyers, she was able...Tibitha was great to work with! She devoted a lot of time with us and her experience was very helpful during our home buying proce... - 5.0
- 5/26/2026
- • reynok7
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha is fantastic! So glad we chose to work with her to get our dream home! What really stood out was how much she went above and beyond. She not only helped us naviga...Tibitha is fantastic! So glad we chose to work with her to get our dream home! What really stood out was how much she went above a...5.0- 5/25/2026
- • Morgan Gray
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Mineral ridge, OH.
We had a wonderful experience working with Tibi! As first-time homebuyers, we were unsure of the process and had plenty of questions and stress along the way. Tibi was in...We had a wonderful experience working with Tibi! As first-time homebuyers, we were unsure of the process and had plenty of questio... - 5.0
- 4/28/2026
- • mikeconnolly1968
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Steelton, Youngstown, OH.
Tibitha went the extra mile for me. I had a property that had some technical issues and she was able to market it and get it sold to the right person. She is very good at...Tibitha went the extra mile for me. I had a property that had some technical issues and she was able to market it and get it sold ...5.0- 4/20/2026
- • rrg242
Sold a Single Family home in 2026 in Youngstown, OH.
Tibby was amazing and made the process seamless. We really appreciate all of her work because we had relocated across the country during the sale of our home. Thank you f...Tibby was amazing and made the process seamless. We really appreciate all of her work because we had relocated across the country ...
