The metric every multifamily operator should be tracking

With renters cautious and choosy, lead quality is the only number worth chasing

multifamily operator on the phone

Written by Zillow on September 30, 2026

Key takeaways

  • One renter now lands in a dozen inboxes and signs just one lease, so a growing pile of leads can hide a shrinking pool of real tenants.
  • With nearly 40% of listings offering free rent to compete, the only marketing number worth bringing to an owner is the cost of a signed lease.
  • The renters who will actually sign give themselves away early, and the operators who spot them fill more units while paying for fewer leads.

In budget meetings this fall, a rental owner will ask their marketer the usual question: how many leads did we get? It sounds like progress, but it barely tells you whether the marketing worked.

Counting leads made sense a few years ago, when renters were plentiful and eager to sign a lease. That market is gone. Rent now runs about $400 a month higher than before the pandemic, up roughly 31%, and renters have grown careful and price-conscious. One renter now messages many properties before signing a single lease, so most of the inquiries an operator gets were never going to become tenants.

A building boom is behind the shift. New apartment construction has pushed the national vacancy rate to 7.3%, up from 5.6% in 2021. With more empty units than renters to fill them, nearly 40% of listings now offer deals like free rent or waived fees, more than double the share before the pandemic. The inbox can be full while the building is not.

So the better question is not how many leads came in, but how good they were. A good lead is a renter who is close to signing: someone who has compared prices, read the lease terms and asked to tour. A weak lead is someone who sent a quick message and disappeared. When apartments were scarce, that difference barely mattered, because almost everyone signed somewhere. Now that renters have choices, most inquiries lead nowhere, and being able to hone in on the serious ones saves operators and marketers time and money.

The good news is that quality is not a guess. Renters show how serious they are by what they do while they shop. They filter by price, read the terms and book a tour, and Zillow can see and count each of those steps. That means an operator can measure lead quality the same way they already measure how many leads came in. And because those actions point to the renters closest to signing, a leasing team can put its time where it pays off instead of treating every message the same.

"Renters are stretched and deliberate, and that changes what a lead is worth," said Kara Ng, a senior economist at Zillow. "The question is no longer how many reached out. It is how many were ever going to sign."

What a serious renter looks like

A serious renter tips their hand long before they sign. Nearly 6 in 10 renters say seeing fees and terms upfront is essential, and more than half will not sign without a private tour first. A renter who reads the terms and asks to tour is telling you they are ready to move. A one-line message and silence rarely is.

Booking a tour is the clearest sign of all. Renters who book an instant tour on Zillow are 3.4 times more likely to sign a lease than those who just send a message. Buildings that let renters book those tours sign 6.8% more of their leads than comparable buildings that do not.

The operators pulling ahead act on those signs. They spend less time on the flood of new messages and more on the renters who show they are ready. Zillow is working to send fewer empty inquiries in the first place, requiring renters to verify their contact information so real people, not spam, reach a leasing team. That can mean fewer messages overall but a larger share that become tenants.

Speed matters just as much, because renters expect answers around the clock and more than half of leasing inquiries arrive outside business hours. Zillow Rentals now embeds AI Assist, an EliseAI-powered leasing agent, directly in its eligible listings, so prospects can get answers, schedule tours and stay engaged the moment they reach out, day or night. It works: renters who use AI Assist are 43% more likely to apply, 19% more likely to book a tour and 24% more likely to sign a lease. An instant, helpful reply keeps serious renters moving while freeing onsite teams to focus on the ones closest to signing.

Smart operators also try to follow each renter past the first message toward the signed lease, not just count who reached out. Inside Zillow Rental Manager, the tool many already use, operators can track tours, applications and other steps that show which leads are turning into tenants, a fuller picture than a raw lead count. The closer they get to tying spending to signed leases, the better they can judge what their marketing is really buying.

These same clues can also show how busy the whole rental market is. When a renter saves a listing or shares it with a roommate, that is a sign they are serious. Zillow's Observed Renter Demand Index adds up those actions across the market to show how many people are seriously looking to rent right now. Because renters browse and save before they ever apply, that measure tends to shift before vacancy does, giving operators an early read on where demand is headed. So when an operator sees their own leads slow down, the index can tell them whether serious renters are pulling back everywhere, a sign the market has cooled, or whether demand is holding and the problem is their own marketing.

Put together, these steps make lead quality something an operator can act on. Instead of a lead count that only says how many people reached out, an operator gets answers to the questions that actually decide the budget.

It shows which spending was worth it. When an operator can see which sources produced signed tenants rather than clicks, they can put more money behind what fills units and stop paying for what only fills the inbox. It shows a leasing team where to start each morning, so agents call the renters who have toured and read the terms before the ones who sent a single message and went quiet. And it shows what is coming, because a rising or falling demand index tells an operator whether to expect a busy leasing season or a slow one, and to staff and price accordingly. 

"When leasing slows, the reflex is to buy more leads. That is usually the wrong move," Ng said. "If half the people contacting you were never going to sign, doubling that number just buries a team that is already stretched. A dollar works harder on fewer, better renters. Let signed leases, not messages, tell you whether it paid off."

Speak with a Zillow expert

Contact us about company news or Zillow research.

Email the PR team

Speak with a Zillow economist

Ask Chief Economist Mischa Fisher and his team about housing trends and Zillow research.

Email the team

Related Articles

real estate agent with home buyers
5 min read

Buyers are frozen waiting for rates to fall. Agents can help them make buying work.

real estate agent shaking hands with clients
5 min read

New products from Zillow further help real estate agents help clients

couple walking down the street
5 min read

The typical renter is now 41. Multifamily marketing must catch up.

illustration of mailbox

Sign up for Zillow news updates

Subscribe to receive daily emails for the latest Zillow news and announcements, product updates and more.

 

By submitting this form, you agree to receive email communication from Zillow. We respect your privacy. See our privacy policy.