$400,000
3 bd2 ba-- -- Montague, NJ
3 bd2 ba-- --
Montague, NJ
Sold 13 days ago
Buyer
Get to know Caitlin Schlaffer
NJ Realtor
As a lifelong Sussex County resident, Caitlin knows perfectly well the exhilarating, yet relaxing lifestyle our beautiful area has to offer. A natural people-person, leader, and problem solver, Caitlin knew her true calling came to life when she began her career as a Real Estate Agent.
Caitlin is as energetic and passionate as they come - if she's not out touring with clients, she’s preparing a listing for one of the many adored neighborhoods of ...
Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentRelocation
Team sales and listings (127)
This map and property list shows the most recent 100 sales and 100 listings
Sold
For sale
Sold (125)
- $400,000
- 3 bd
- 2 ba
- -- sqft
7 New Myrtle Dr, Montague, NJ 07827Sold 13 days agoBuyer - $1,300,000
- 3 bd
- 3 ba
- -- sqft
116 Chincopee Rd, Lake Hopatcong, NJ 07849Sold 2 months agoSeller - $1,723,000
- 4 bd
- 5 ba
- -- sqft
25 Lamerson Rd, Chester, NJ 07930Sold 3 months agoSeller - $1,400,000
- 5 bd
- 6 ba
- -- sqft
9 Mills Ridge, Sparta, NJ 07871Sold 3 months agoBuyer - $435,000
- 3 bd
- 3 ba
- -- sqft
105 Andover Sparta Rd, Newton, NJ 07860Sold 3 months agoBuyer
For sale (2)
- $700,000
- 4 bd
- 4 ba
- 3,080 sqft
38 Dyer Rd, Wantage, NJ 07461House for SaleOpen: Sun 1-3pm (9/13)
Keller Williams Integrity - $625,000
- 3 bd
- 3 ba
- -- sqft
7 George St, Mine Hill, NJ 07803House for SaleBreezeway with extra storage
Team reviews (44)
Reviews represent all team members.
- 5.0
- 1/31/2026
- • Gabriella Rodriguez
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Andover twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferMy husband and I are first time home buyers, and we discovered Caitlin months before closing on our home; all I can say is what a blessing! Caitlin is extremely experienc...My husband and I are first time home buyers, and we discovered Caitlin months before closing on our home; all I can say is what a ...5.0- 1/25/2026
- • Peter Crandall
Bought a Single Family home in 2026 in Frankford twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferFirst time buyer here. Caitlin was the third agent we came across after the first two didn't seem like the best fit. Glad we chose our agent carefully and landed with Cai...First time buyer here. Caitlin was the third agent we came across after the first two didn't seem like the best fit. Glad we chose... - 5.0
- 10/1/2025
- • abbeythomas29
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Lake mohawk, Sparta twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferCaitlin was our agent in selling our home and purchasing a new one, all within a few months. She did an absolutely incredible job from the time we met her to the closing....Caitlin was our agent in selling our home and purchasing a new one, all within a few months. She did an absolutely incredible job ...5.0- 6/26/2025
- • melissaandallan
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Andover twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferIt took us over 3 years to find our new home and Caitlin stuck by us through the whole process. Once we were under contract, she helped us through the entire process righ...It took us over 3 years to find our new home and Caitlin stuck by us through the whole process. Once we were under contract, she h... - 5.0
- 2/27/2025
- • higginsj1121
Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Wallkill lake, Vernon twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferFrom start to finish, Caitlin was an expert, on top of every little detail to ensure a smooth, speedy listing and close, all while attracting a HUGE amount of buyers. Not...From start to finish, Caitlin was an expert, on top of every little detail to ensure a smooth, speedy listing and close, all while...You know when you meet someone and you can just tell that they don’t just show up to work for the paycheck, but are actually passionate about their work? That’s Caitlin- ...You know when you meet someone and you can just tell that they don’t just show up to work for the paycheck, but are actually passi... - 5.0
- 12/21/2024
- • agslavin
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Wantage twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferCaitlin was a incredible and invaluable asset in our home selling and buying experience. Our sale was hampered by numerous road blocks, an emergent birth and countless ot...Caitlin was a incredible and invaluable asset in our home selling and buying experience. Our sale was hampered by numerous road bl...5.0- 11/10/2024
- • Shannon Mahoney
Sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Lake mohawk, Byram twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferTHE BEST! Caitlin was beyond phenomenal to work with. From the start, she proved how dedicated she was to ensuring the process was smooth and helping us make educated dec...THE BEST! Caitlin was beyond phenomenal to work with. From the start, she proved how dedicated she was to ensuring the process was... - 5.0
- 10/9/2024
- • conner casterline
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Hampton twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferChoosing Caitlin to be our realtor was the BEST decision we could have made. Caitlin represented us with both selling and purchasing our new home at the same time. Not on...Choosing Caitlin to be our realtor was the BEST decision we could have made. Caitlin represented us with both selling and purchasi...5.0- 4/1/2024
- • johnnypalumbo
Bought a Single Family home in 2024 in Hampton twp., NJ.
Review for: Caitlin SchlafferFive stars in every category! I cannot recommend for your real estate needs! I recently had the pleasure of working with Caitlyn to buy back an old family home…a long ti...Five stars in every category! I cannot recommend for your real estate needs! I recently had the pleasure of working with Caitlyn ...
