$1,525,000
3 bd3 ba1,697 sqft East Hampton, NY
3 bd3 ba1,697 sqft
East Hampton, NY
Sold 8 months ago
Seller
Get to know Susan C Cincotta
Real Estate Broker
Susan C Cincotta, CBR, RSSR
Real Estate Broker
Certified Buyer Representative (CBR)
East End 2nd Place Top Producer 2013
Office Listing Leader, 1st place 2012, 2015 2nd Place 2018, 3rd place 2016, 2017, 2019
Office Production Leader, 1st place, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2016, 2017, 2018, 3rd Place 2019
Office Unit Leader 1st place 2016, 2018, 2nd place 2017, 3rd place 2019
Certificate in Short Sales (RSSR)
Top Producer Shelter Island 1st Place 2...
Specialties
40 Years of experienceBuyer's AgentListing AgentVacation / Short-term RentalsNew Construction
Susan C Cincotta's listings & sales (71)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (1)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 90 Peconic Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964
| 5 Bed, 4 Bath | $5,415,000 |
Sold (70)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4/11/2025 | $1,525,000 | Seller | ||
| 6/13/2024 | $2,825,000 | Seller | ||
| 5/28/2024 | $495,000 | Buyer | ||
| 7/14/2023 | $1,120,000 | Buyer | ||
| 5/16/2022 | $1,475,000 | Buyer |
Susan C Cincotta's reviews (20)
- 5.0
- 4/16/2025
- • jojoandbunny
Sold a home in 2025.
susan helped with a quick sale of home. went above and beyond to make this happen in a timely fashion, ironing out all the many details to make the closing happen faster ...susan helped with a quick sale of home. went above and beyond to make this happen in a timely fashion, ironing out all the many de...5.0- 6/14/2024
- • Darshan Somashekar
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Shelter island, NY.
Susan was the sales broker that sold us our beautiful Shelter Island home initially. She was so good that we decided to use her as our sales broker when we moved and sold...Susan was the sales broker that sold us our beautiful Shelter Island home initially. She was so good that we decided to use her as... - 5.0
- 5/15/2021
- • Karine Rosenberg
Bought a home in 2020 in Shelter Island, NY.
Susan worked with us for many years, renting and helping us to find and buy our home. She is very easy to work with! We appreciated all the time and energy she spent wi...Susan worked with us for many years, renting and helping us to find and buy our home. She is very easy to work with! We apprecia...5.0- 5/2/2021
- • jrosenberg05
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Shelter island, NY.
Susan patiently worked with my wife and I over many years while we looked for the house we wanted. She is incredibly responsive and knowledgeable. But in the end, it’s th...Susan patiently worked with my wife and I over many years while we looked for the house we wanted. She is incredibly responsive an... - 5.0
- 1/13/2021
- • drdinahsaur
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Shelter island, NY.
I recently had to sell a family home on Shelter Island. I had no idea where to begin. I was fortunate to have Susan as my real estate agent, although she was much more th...I recently had to sell a family home on Shelter Island. I had no idea where to begin. I was fortunate to have Susan as my real est...5.0- 12/7/2020
- • rubin margery
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Shelter island, NY.
I couldn't be more happy and thrilled with Susan"s attention to detail and where withal to make this happen. I actual had two offers on the house and we had a contract o...I couldn't be more happy and thrilled with Susan"s attention to detail and where withal to make this happen. I actual had two off... - 5.0
- 11/1/2020
- • dleeastin
Sold a Apartment home in 2020 in Hampton bays, NY.
We recommend Susan Cincotta very highly. She has sold 2 houses for us. In both of the sales we were under emotional stress. Her compassion and helpfulness were absolut...We recommend Susan Cincotta very highly. She has sold 2 houses for us. In both of the sales we were under emotional stress. Her...5.0- 10/3/2019
- • Max Osterweis
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Shelter island, NY.
We have worked with Susan on a number of deals - she helped us find a rental, she helped us find a home to buy, she helped us find land to buy, and she has helped us sell...We have worked with Susan on a number of deals - she helped us find a rental, she helped us find a home to buy, she helped us find... - 5.0
- 7/15/2018
- • Darshan Somashekar
Bought a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island, NY.
Susan helped us with our Shelter Island purchase. She was very thorough and quick. She also helped us understand what services we needed before and after purchase and it'...Susan helped us with our Shelter Island purchase. She was very thorough and quick. She also helped us understand what services we ...5.0- 4/20/2018
- • dleeastin
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Hampton bays, NY.
We can recommend Susan very highly. Although we only had a small cottage for sale, she put so much effort into selling it. She guided us through the process in great det...We can recommend Susan very highly. Although we only had a small cottage for sale, she put so much effort into selling it. She gu...
