- 3 bds
- 4 ba
- 3,801 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY
Private sandy beach
Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale
108 results
- 8c Pheasant Circle, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 45 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1,265 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESWood burning fireplace
Loading...
- 6 Cozy Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,424 sqft
LISTING BY: DERING HARBOR REAL ESTATEInviting fireplace
- 12 Ginny Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,467 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYWood burning fireplace
- 14 Crescent Way, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 3,059 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPrice cut: $145,000 (8/10)
- 6 Harbor Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 7 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,500 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATEOversized windows
- Outdoor fireplace
- 4 Sheep Pasture Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 1,832 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESRaised fireplace
- Private dock
- 4 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,920 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATERefined yet inviting atmosphere
Loading...
- 5 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,157 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESOriginal moldings
- 126 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,540 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYIndependent two-bedroom casita
- Undisclosed Address, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2,407 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESDramatic rooftop observation deck
- 171 N Ferry Rd #J/g, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,000 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPSouth facing balcony deck
- Waterfront estate
- 20 Sunshine Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 4,901 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATEBeautifully appointed interiors
- 66 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 7 bds
- 10 ba
- 5,042 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYPrivate beach
Shelter Island housing market
The average sale price of a house in Shelter Island NY is .
89For sale listings13.5%Listings with price drops-Average days to pendingStrong buyer Market temperature- 15 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 3,370 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESContemporary waterfront
- 20 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 7 bds
- 6 ba
- 5,000 sqft
LISTING BY: HEDGEROW EXCLUSIVE PROPERTIESModern comforts
- 33 Dinah Rock Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 4 ba
- 4,875 sqft
LISTING BY: HEDGEROW EXCLUSIVE PROPERTIESArt studio
- 32 Hilo Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 2,237 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPDeep-water dock
- West-facing waterfront retreat
- 24 Rocky Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2,890 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPrice cut: $500,000 (8/15)
- 16 Bowditch Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,266 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYPrice cut: $200,001 (8/14)
- 12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 4,200 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYPrice cut: $150,000 (8/25)
- 15 N Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,401 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESCedar-shingled cottage
- 11 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,187 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESFloor-to-ceiling windows
- 10 Point Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 5,386 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATESpacious laundry room
- 7 Fox Hollow Run, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 3,038 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPrice cut: $160,000 (8/20)
- Waterfront boathouse
- 7 Locust Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2,007 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESGlass-enclosed laundry area
- 7 Fox Hollow Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 3,038 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPrice cut: $160,000 (8/20)
- 5 Sea Gull Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,072 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYExpansive primary suite
- 47 Ram Island Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 6 ba
- 6,477 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATECentral island
- Regulation-size racquetball court
- 7 Locust Ave #&-4, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2,007 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESBluestone patio
- Custom white oak cabinetry
- 4 Irene Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,028 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY99 days on Zillow
- 3 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,851 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES34 days on Zillow
- 43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 6,106 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYFully finished lower level
- 60 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2,854 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPTwo car garage
to get email alerts when listings hit the market.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-08-30 16:32:59 PDT All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. [Click here for more information](/mls-disclaimers/#778)
Buying a Home in Shelter Island NY: Frequently Asked Questions
Are home values going up or down in Shelter Island NY?
This month the median home value in Shelter Island is $2,314,034. Change since last month: +1.0%. Change since this time last year: 6.2%.
Is Shelter Island NY a buyer's or seller's market?
Based on the Zillow Market Temperature, Shelter Island is currently a Strong buyer market. This measures how quickly homes are selling and how much competition buyers face, so a seller's market favors sellers with faster sales and more competition, while a buyer's market gives buyers more time and negotiating room.
