- 2 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,200 sqft
LISTING BY: SIMON HARRISON REAL ESTATE
17 hours ago
Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Homes For Sale
96 results
- 4 Duvall Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 Harbor Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 7 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,500 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATEOversized windows
Loading...
- 5 Spring Garden Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 5 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,845 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYOpen: Sun 12-2pm (5/31)
- 2 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 3 ba
- 5,900 sqft
LISTING BY: COMPASS GREATER NY LLCThree income-producing historic cottages
- Beautiful stone fireplace
- 5 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,157 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPrice cut: $200,000 (5/19)
- 58 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 3,200 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPPool house
- 1 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 0.4 acres lot
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESPristine acreage
- Waterfront estate
- Open: Sun 1:30-3:30pm (5/31)
Loading...
- 7 Locust Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2,007 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESFinished bonus room - 27 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,100 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYIn-ground pool - 8 Little Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 8 bds
- 10 ba
- 8,000 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYNatural stone - 47 Ram Island Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 6 ba
- 6,477 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATECentral island - 4 Irene Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,028 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYPrice cut: $125,000 (5/22) - Modern functionality
- 12 Terry Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 5 bds
- 5 ba
- 4,200 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYOpen: Sun 1:30-3pm (5/31) - 13 Winthrop Road #24, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
- 1 bd
- 1 ba
- 39,964 sqft
LISTING BY: BROWN HARRIS STEVENS HAMPTONSHeated pool - Outdoor summer dining enjoyment
- Expansive glass
- Regulation-size racquetball court
- 32 Hilo Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 5 ba
- 2,237 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPFinished lower level - 15 N Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 3 bds
- 2 ba
- 1,401 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESCedar-shingled cottage - 11 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,000 sqft
LISTING BY: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATEOpen: Sun 1:30-2:30pm (5/31) - 60 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2,854 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPTwo car garage - 29 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 2,939 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESGunite pool - 13 Winthrop Rd Unit 24, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 1 bd
- 1 ba
- -- sqft
LISTING BY: BROWN HARRIS STEVENSBosch appliances - Cozy fireplace
- 126 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,540 sqft
LISTING BY: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYIndependent two-bedroom casita - Waterfront boathouse
- 7 Locust Ave #&-4, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 4 bds
- 2 ba
- 2,007 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESFinished bonus room - 66-A N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 2 bds
- 3 ba
- 1,488 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATESSpring-fed pond - Charming shingled home
- 100 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1,626 sqft
LISTING BY: M WEIN REALTY INC.Wood burning fireplace - 24 Rocky Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 3 ba
- 2,890 sqft
LISTING BY: SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES191 days on Zillow - 20 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 7 bds
- 6 ba
- 5,000 sqft
LISTING BY: HEDGEROW EXCLUSIVE PROPERTIESModern comforts - 5 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 5 bds
- 6 ba
- 4,495 sqft
LISTING BY: CORCORAN GROUPFinished lower level - 11 Mimosa Pl, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
- 3 bds
- 3 ba
- 1,564 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYOpen: Sun 11:30am-1pm (5/31) - Scenic waterfront backdrop
- 141A N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 7 ba
- 4,400 sqft
LISTING BY: ATLAS SALES REALTY LLCGunite pool - 26 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 4 bds
- 4 ba
- 1,702 sqft
LISTING BY: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTYPrice cut: $100,000 (5/16)
to get email alerts when listings hit the market.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-02-06 15:18:24 PST. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. [Click here for more information](/mls-disclaimers/#778)
- For Sale
- New York
- Suffolk County
- Shelter Island
Find a Home You'll Love
Explore Nearby & Average Home Values
- East Hampton Homes for Sale$2,007,562
- Southampton Homes for Sale$2,204,606
- Old Saybrook Homes for Sale$677,878
- Old Lyme Homes for Sale$657,236
- Sag Harbor Homes for Sale$2,260,138
- Southold Homes for Sale$1,124,185
- Greenport Homes for Sale$982,820
- Mattituck Homes for Sale$1,004,751
- Cutchogue Homes for Sale$1,222,878
- Water Mill Homes for Sale$4,644,141
- Bridgehampton Homes for Sale$4,600,461
- Sagaponack Homes for Sale$7,576,339
- Peconic Homes for Sale$1,236,353
- New Suffolk Homes for Sale-
- Laurel Homes for Sale$1,016,033
- Amagansett Homes for Sale$2,919,494
- East Marion Homes for Sale$1,193,687
- Orient Homes for Sale$1,531,163
- Wainscott Homes for Sale$3,791,596
- Springs Homes for Sale$1,404,298
- East Hampton North Homes for Sale$2,005,964
- Northwest Harbor Homes for Sale$2,065,831
- Southampton Village Homes for Sale$4,141,412
- North Sea Homes for Sale$1,567,563
- Noyack Homes for Sale$1,815,766
- Essex Village Homes for Sale$778,313
- Westbrook Center Homes for Sale-
- Madison Center Homes for Sale-
- Old Saybrook Center Homes for Sale$719,791
- Northville Homes for Sale$920,267
- Greenport West Homes for Sale$929,528
- Jamesport Homes for Sale$916,695
- East Hampton Village Homes for Sale$5,424,533
- Dering Harbor Homes for Sale-
- North Haven Homes for Sale$3,431,319
- Saybrook Manor Homes for Sale$633,272
- Napeague Homes for Sale$2,185,112
- 11937 Homes for Sale$1,934,983
- 11968 Homes for Sale$2,193,073
- 11963 Homes for Sale$2,340,347
- 11971 Homes for Sale$1,119,672
- 11944 Homes for Sale$984,834
- 11952 Homes for Sale$1,004,087
- 11976 Homes for Sale$4,939,948
- 11935 Homes for Sale$1,222,859
- 11964 Homes for Sale$1,700,130
- 11939 Homes for Sale$1,199,314
- 11957 Homes for Sale$1,528,803
- 11958 Homes for Sale$1,237,549
- 11932 Homes for Sale$4,635,149
- 11965 Homes for Sale$2,025,913
- 11930 Homes for Sale$3,169,660
- 11948 Homes for Sale$1,016,535
- 11962 Homes for Sale$6,501,108
- 11975 Homes for Sale$3,129,916
Disclaimer: School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Pitney Bowes and are subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.
About the ratings: GreatSchools ratings are based on a comparison of test results for all schools in the state. It is designed to be a starting point to help parents make baseline comparisons, not the only factor in selecting the right school for your family. Learn more
