Skip main navigation

Cynthia Hostetler

Brightstar Real Estate ServicesLead of The Hostetler TEAM
5.07 team reviews
Contact the team
Team

Recent Sales

Sales numbers represent all team members
Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $55,000
    -- bd-- ba-- -- Wolcottville, IN
    -- bd-- ba-- --
    Wolcottville, IN
    Sold 15 days ago
    BuyerSeller
    102 W Dutch St, Wolcottville, IN, 46795
  • $198,000
    3 bd2 ba1,404 sqft Wolcottville, IN
    3 bd2 ba1,404 sqft
    Wolcottville, IN
    Sold 22 days ago
    Seller
    100 W Dutch St, Wolcottville, IN, 46795
  • $230,000
    2 bd1 ba960 sqft Howe, IN
    2 bd1 ba960 sqft
    Howe, IN
    Sold 24 days ago
    BuyerSeller
    1920 W 570 N, Howe, IN, 46746
  • $255,000
    3 bd2 ba1,200 sqft Lagrange, IN
    3 bd2 ba1,200 sqft
    Lagrange, IN
    Sold 2 months ago
    Seller
    150 W 60 S, Lagrange, IN, 46761
  • $84,000
    1 bd1 ba504 sqft Shipshewana, IN
    1 bd1 ba504 sqft
    Shipshewana, IN
    Sold 3 months ago
    BuyerSeller
    Independence Way #330-332, Shipshewana, IN, 46565
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
13
Sales last 12 months
128
Total sales
$40K-$650K
Price range
$226K
Average price

Meet The Hostetler TEAM

Get to know The Hostetler TEAM

Real Estate Broker

Cynthia grew up in the LaGrange County area and graduated from Westview High School in 1979. Shortly after, she started a family when she married her husband, Brad, on April 11th, 1980. Together they have one daughter, Kara and granddaughter Olivia. Cynthia & her husband Brad reside in Shipshewana & enjoy the rural Northeast Indiana lifestyle.

Cynthia started out as a hairdresser and went on to be a business owner for 12 years. In 2002, Cynthia...

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentForeclosureCommercial PropertiesNew Construction
24 Years of experience
Visit team website
FacebookXLinkedIn

Team sales and listings (129)

This map and property list shows the most recent 100 sales and 100 listings

Sold
For sale
Skip sales and listings map
Go back to the sales and listings map

Sold (128)

Skip to the end of the carousel
Skip to the beginning of the carousel

For sale (1)

Skip to the end of the carousel
Skip to the beginning of the carousel

Team reviews (7)

Reviews represent all team members.

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • 5.0
    • 9/30/2026
    • • Morgan Lynn

    Bought and sold a Mobile / Manufactured home in 2026 in Wolcottville, IN.

    Review for: Cynthia Hostetler
    Cynthia is the BEST realtor I have ever worked with. From the second we met her, we instantly felt comfortable and knew we were in good hands. She is knowledgeable, works...
    Cynthia is the BEST realtor I have ever worked with. From the second we met her, we instantly felt comfortable and knew we were in...
    5.0
    • 6/11/2025
    • • Dj432361

    Sold a Single Family home in 2025 in Howe, IN.

    Review for: Kara Rosentreter
    Working with Kara was wonderful. She made the whole process easy. Our home was only on the market for 20 days. Whole process was fast which is what we wanted. This is the...
    Working with Kara was wonderful. She made the whole process easy. Our home was only on the market for 20 days. Whole process was f...
  • 5.0
    • 12/19/2018
    • • zuser20151202154002295

    Bought a Single Family home in 2018 in Goshen, IN.

    Review for: Kara Rosentreter
    With this being out first home purchase we had no idea where to start. Kara and Cynthia went above and beyond to make sure my wife and I knew exactly what we were looking...
    With this being out first home purchase we had no idea where to start. Kara and Cynthia went above and beyond to make sure my wife...
    5.0
    • 10/1/2018
    • • jeffbowman96

    Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Howe, IN.

    Review for: Kara Rosentreter
    The team handled everything exceptionally well and got us from listing to closing with no hiccups. Issues with the inspection and appraisal were dealt with promptly. Dur...
    The team handled everything exceptionally well and got us from listing to closing with no hiccups. Issues with the inspection and...
  • 5.0
    • 9/20/2018
    • • pbontrager1

    Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Lagrange, IN.

    Review for: Kara Rosentreter
    Our experience was great, we highly recommend! The Hostetler Team was very knowledgeable of the area and helped us sell the property in no time. They are very friendly an...
    Our experience was great, we highly recommend! The Hostetler Team was very knowledgeable of the area and helped us sell the proper...
    5.0
    • 8/14/2017
    • • john9656

    Bought a home in 2016 in IN 46540.

    Review for: Cynthia Hostetler
    I have worked with many real estate people on many properties for over 40 years . These ladies are a cut above them all .!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    I have worked with many real estate people on many properties for over 40 years . These ladies are a cut above them all .!!!!!!!!!...
  • 5.0
    • 12/28/2016
    • • VANDAM0

    Sold a Single Family home in 2016 in Lagrange, IN.

    Review for: Cynthia Hostetler
    WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR ALL OF CYNTHIA'S HELP IN THE SALE OF OUR HOUSE. AS IT IS A STRESSFUL TIME, SHE HELPED US THROUGH THE PROCESS. THANKS; KARIN VANDAM
    WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR ALL OF CYNTHIA'S HELP IN THE SALE OF OUR HOUSE. AS IT IS A STRESSFUL TIME, SHE HELPED US THROUGH THE PROCESS. ...
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
Add a review

Service areas (7)

TEAM

Cynthia Hostetler

Brightstar Real Estate ServicesLead of The Hostetler TEAM
5.07 team reviews
13sales last 12 months
128total sales
$40K-$650Kprice range
$226Kaverage price
24years of experience
(260) 336-1376
(260) 336-1376
cynthia@thehostetlerteam.com
55137 St Rd 13
Middlebury, IN, 46540