$3,695,000
4 bd4 ba4,229 sqft Shelter Island Heights, NY
4 bd4 ba4,229 sqft
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Sold 21 days ago
Buyer
Get to know Penelope Moore
Lic Associate RE Broker,
The honesty, integrity, dedication and professionalism Penelope Moore has exhibited throughout her nearly 30-year real estate career have earned her great success not only in both the residential and commercial markets, but in the loyal relationships she's formed along the way. Always there to help her clients, Penelope boasts a well-deserved reputation for making the real estate process simple, successful and stress-free for every buyer and sell...
Specialties
36 Years of experienceBuyer's AgentListing AgentForeclosureProperty Management
Penelope Moore's listings & sales (401)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (23)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 24 Rocky Point Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
| 4 Bed, 3 Bath | $3,600,000 |
 29 E Brander Pkwy Shelter Island, NY 11964
| 4 Bed, 4 Bath | $5,350,000 |
 55 Peconic Ave Shelter Island, NY 11964
| 3 Bed, 3 Bath | $2,950,000 |
 7 Locust Ave #&-4 Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
| 4 Bed, 2 Bath | $1,850,000 |
 7 Locust Ave Shelter Island, NY 11965
| 4 Bed, 2 Bath | $1,850,000 |
Sold (378)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11/21/2025 | $3,695,000 | Buyer | ||
| 10/28/2025 | $990,000 | Seller | ||
| 10/17/2025 | $1,845,000 | Seller | ||
| 10/10/2025 | $2,250,000 | Buyer and Seller | ||
| 9/29/2025 | $1,675,000 | Seller |
Penelope Moore's reviews (17)
- 5.0
- 11/7/2019
- • user598780
Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Shelter island, NY.
Penelope helped me sell my home within the the frame I had in mind and to buyers who appreciated the intrinsic value of my property. A very good local real estate agent w...Penelope helped me sell my home within the the frame I had in mind and to buyers who appreciated the intrinsic value of my propert...5.0- 6/7/2019
- • tenneson7
Sold a Single Family home in 2019 in Shelter island, NY.
Penny helped me sell a house where I was Executor of an estate-and I live 3,000 miles away. So Penny had to deal with many of the day-to-day issues that an owner would us...Penny helped me sell a house where I was Executor of an estate-and I live 3,000 miles away. So Penny had to deal with many of the ... - 5.0
- 7/9/2018
- • taylorcsimons
Bought a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island, NY.
Penny is the best agent on the island and would be in any market she chooses to work in. We recently worked with Penny and she found us the perfect home for us (no easy f...Penny is the best agent on the island and would be in any market she chooses to work in. We recently worked with Penny and she fou...5.0- 5/28/2018
- • semryan366
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island, NY.
Our experience with Penelope Moore (Saunders Real Estate) for the sale of our home was completely positive. Her years of experience in the Shelter Island market provided ...Our experience with Penelope Moore (Saunders Real Estate) for the sale of our home was completely positive. Her years of experienc... - 5.0
- 3/30/2018
- • mchlde1960
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island heights, NY.
Penelope was an invaluable resource to us when we sold our house on Shelter Island. Penelope facilitated the sale with a high level of professionalism, was actively invol...Penelope was an invaluable resource to us when we sold our house on Shelter Island. Penelope facilitated the sale with a high leve...5.0- 3/5/2018
- • pom Shillingford
Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Shelter island, NY.
The process of selling our home through Penelope could not have been less painless. She knows the market inside out, was honest, straightforward and extremely professiona...The process of selling our home through Penelope could not have been less painless. She knows the market inside out, was honest, s... - 5.0
- 2/28/2018
- • rduffy98
Sold a Single Family home in 2017 in Shelter island, NY.
Penny was a great asset to us during the entire sales process. She has high localmarket knowledge, was very active/responsive in marketing our home, and followed through...Penny was a great asset to us during the entire sales process. She has high localmarket knowledge, was very active/responsive in ...5.0- 2/24/2018
- • mjmuntean
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island, NY.
Penny is a really great agent -- we couldn't recommend her more highly. In selling our house, we found her to be a tireless worker, constantly thinking of the best way to...Penny is a really great agent -- we couldn't recommend her more highly. In selling our house, we found her to be a tireless worker... - 5.0
- 2/22/2018
- • Christine Houston
Sold a Single Family home in 2018 in Shelter island, NY.
I came to Penelope based on her excellent reputation. She did not disappoint. The sale of my home involved a very difficult, controlling, buyer. There were no issues with...I came to Penelope based on her excellent reputation. She did not disappoint. The sale of my home involved a very difficult, contr...5.0- 4/27/2016
- • dolphinmtc
Sold a Single Family home in 2016 in Shelter island, NY.
I listed two Shelter Island houses with Penelope Moore. One has already sold. I couldn't be happier with Penelope's hands-on professional approach. She is realistic about...I listed two Shelter Island houses with Penelope Moore. One has already sold. I couldn't be happier with Penelope's hands-on profe...
