$2,345,000
4 bd4 ba5,100 sqft Mattituck, NY
4 bd4 ba5,100 sqft
Mattituck, NY
Sold 2 months ago
Buyer
Get to know the team
Broker
It's about community... Thomas McCarthy, a lifelong North Fork resident, along with his wife Susan, has a deep commitment to and an understanding of everything that makes the East End of Long Island great. Supporters of land preservation, intelligent development and civic participation, the McCarthy family cherishes the North Fork and works hard to help others participate in its future. An investment in the McCarthy team is an investment in the f...
Specialties
Property Management
SpeaksEnglish, Spanish
36 Years of experienceTeam listings & sales (577)
For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.
For Sale (7)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 870 Horton Ave Mattituck, NY 11952
| 4 Bed, 2 Bath | $709,000 |
 385 New Suffolk Ave Mattituck, NY 11952
| $2,075,000 | |
 55975 Route 25 Southold, NY 11971
| $1,600,000 | |
 470 Goose Creek Ln Southold, NY 11971
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $2,399,000 |
 530 Sunset Way Southold, NY 11971
| 5 Bed, 2 Bath | $1,699,000 |
For Rent (4)
Address | Bed/Bath | Listing price |
|---|---|---|
 215 Northfield Ln Southold, NY 11971
| 4 Bed, 3 Bath | $13,000/mo |
 1100 Pine Ave Southold, NY 11971
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $5,000/mo |
 49925 Route 25 Southold, NY 11971
| 2 Bed, 1 Bath | $3,200/mo |
 3400 Youngs Ave Southold, NY 11971
| 3 Bed, 2 Bath | $4,000/mo |
Sold (566)
Address | Sold date | Closing price | Represented | Flag Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/19/2025 | $2,345,000 | Buyer | ||
| 11/12/2025 | $864,000 | Buyer and Seller | ||
| 11/7/2025 | $2,350,000 | Buyer | ||
| 10/29/2025 | $750,000 | Buyer and Seller | ||
| 10/28/2025 | $999,999 | Seller |
Team reviews (108)
Reviews represent all team members.
- Colin was great to work with and made finding my rental super easy. He was responsive, knowledgeable, and really knew a lot about the area. The whole process was smooth f...Colin was great to work with and made finding my rental super easy. He was responsive, knowledgeable, and really knew a lot about ...Our experience with Thomas was terrific. From the original consultation to the exchanging of checks at the closing, Tom was personally involved and helped navigate the wh...Our experience with Thomas was terrific. From the original consultation to the exchanging of checks at the closing, Tom was person...
- Tom and his team at McCarthy Real Estate are top notch! They did an excellent job throughout the entire process - from readying the home for sale all the way to the clos...Tom and his team at McCarthy Real Estate are top notch! They did an excellent job throughout the entire process - from readying t...Awesome person listens to needs and concerns…very knowledgeable with getting ahead of co issues and problems that may arise with inspections Tom and his team are great t...Awesome person listens to needs and concerns…very knowledgeable with getting ahead of co issues and problems that may arise with i...
- 5.0
- 12/17/2023
- • Marythompson19826
Bought a Single Family home in 2023 in Southold, NY.
Review for: TMcCarthyREWe have been looking at houses with Tom McCarthy for about two years, which is proof that Tom was patient and understanding throughout our search process. Tom is very kno...We have been looking at houses with Tom McCarthy for about two years, which is proof that Tom was patient and understanding throug...Tom is reliable, responsive and professional. He was there to assist every step of the selling process, helping to resolve any issues that arose along the way. His knowle...Tom is reliable, responsive and professional. He was there to assist every step of the selling process, helping to resolve any iss... - Tom did a great job of selling our home. He was a great communicator throughout the process…always easy to reach when we had a question. He helped with meeting with inspe...Tom did a great job of selling our home. He was a great communicator throughout the process…always easy to reach when we had a que...Tom is unique as he is not only a broker, but an expert contractor with a keen sense of design and construction issues. He is serving as our general contractor on the ho...Tom is unique as he is not only a broker, but an expert contractor with a keen sense of design and construction issues. He is ser...
- 5.0
- 9/17/2022
- • beverlykendall215
Bought a Condo home in 2022 in Riverhead, NY.
Review for: TMcCarthyREMcCarthy real estate made themselves available when I had questions or needed guidance navigating the sale of my property and purchase of my new property. Their knowledg...McCarthy real estate made themselves available when I had questions or needed guidance navigating the sale of my property and purc...5.0- 9/16/2022
- • Joan Quinn-Roache
Sold a Single Family home in 2022 in Laurel, NY.
Review for: TMcCarthyREFrom day one Tom and his whole staff took the time and personal interest & effort to help secure a buyer for my home. It seemed as if they were my friends helping do thin...From day one Tom and his whole staff took the time and personal interest & effort to help secure a buyer for my home. It seemed as...
